P-man

Frawley's decision-making at times was definitely poor, but he was still very strong in the contests. He had a good game overall.

Petterd's should be "best on ground".

Was just reading through the game thread at bigfooty. We won back alot of respect from the football community today. Every non-Collingwood fan in agreement that the MFC was robbed of a win by the maggots.

There was a holding the ball call on the wing against Melbourne (can't remember which player) which was one of the most ridiculous I've ever seen. Not even half a second prior.

6. Petterd 5. Grimes 4. Jamar 3. Davey 2. Green 1. Dunn

He's copped a bit of a whacking on here the past week but he played out of his shell today. Well done.

There are alot of players who can hold their heads high today. I'm not sure that we shouldn't be running out with almost the exact same team next week against the crows.

Eddie obviously gave an Easter bonus to a few umpires today. Some disgraceful decisions, the majority of which went against us.

That was an emotional whirlwind. I almost don't know how to feel right now. Brilliant effort from the boys. Outstanding.

[censored] it all to hell.

Yeah he needed to take that grab. Still this is amazing to watch.

Dunstall is such a condescending fat turd.

Bailey needs to single him out and give him a blast.

After watching today I'd like to change my vote on our chances in Round 4 to "Likely".

This is the best I've seen Petterd play.

Bate sticking out like a sore thumb at the moment. Everyone's work rate has doubled from last week, except his. Jogging does not equal chasing..

Dunn getting in Maxwell's dial. Terrific stuff.

Better...much, much, much better...

We need to take a leaf out of Collingwood's book and apply some desperation forward line pressure. Oh right..we need a forward line...

Cheers for that.

Buy a membership ya lazy bugger. Comes with a free teatowel, er, scarf.

They could lose every game this season and my scarf would still be safe. I mean it's usually pretty safe...it doesn't get waved too often.

I shudder to think what they're gonna do to our boys if they start like they did against the Doggies. Forget 50 points. It'll be a 70-80 point first term! This is one instance where I agree that a competitive showing will be the aim.

Precisely. I've often thought about this. The implications of free agency are far greater for a club such as Melbourne if we can't extinguish the losing culture that continues to fester. I recall reading that Scully was already showing signs of being less than happy with his current residence, and with Watts coming out of contract, it's something we need to be thinking about now not later. And the prize for most condescending post of the year goes to..

You'd dump McKenzie? He was in our top 4 or 5 yesterday.