Brayshaw Self

Agree completely, although Hannebury had the best beep test result at the draft camp in his year

I don't want to have to hear Luke Darcy say 'He's had a few amateur bouts in his time' or 'He's quite handy with the gloves, BT' every MFC game i watch for the next 8 years.

How can people froth over the prospect of bringing in Riley, Michie, Newton, Magner, Couch, who were all completely unproven at AFL level, whilst denigrating Melksham, who has played some good footy at AFL level in one of the most horrific environments for a sporting team in world history? Melksham played some great footy in the first half of this year as a half-forward. Goodwin will have slightly more insight than most here.

Adding people like Cross and Lumumba keeps our head above water while we develop young players and has a positive effect on culture.

Mackay sucks

We need to keep Fitzy and Spencer, particularly with Jamar likely finishing up. Mature tall depth is invaluable over 23 rounds (and hopefully a couple more weeks)

Daniel Cross

Mark Chopper Reid (Comedian) dafuq

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/video/2015-04-04/rd-1-highlights-melbourne-v-gold-coast 47 seconds in, Clint. It looks like he has springs in his boots.

vandenBerg always seems to get his arms free in the tackle and gives off cleanly and his 'cut' inside Saad and kick to Garlett for Jeffy's first goal was a thing of beauty. I also loved when he decked the living shlt out of Rischitelli in the centre square.

NO!

7.9 for agility is ridiculous

Salem doesn't lose one on ones. He usually even neutralises two on ones. When he's over his thyroid problems and isn't such a fatty, he will be fine. He's a footy player and he can kick it.

The difference in height between Caleb Daniel and Dion Prestia is the same as the difference in height between Prestia and Brent Moloney. It's huge.

I agree with STMJ for the most part. Perhaps you aren't seeing things that are there, Machsy.

I would love to get Petracca and Laverde. They fill two desperate needs for us.

Dillon Viojo-Rainbow - draft this man

Tyson's right-footed inside 50 in the last quarter was a real momentum killer. Was being chased down but should have produced a better kick

Mate, you abused me last year when I raised Dunstan's name; now look at him. Don't be so dismissive of people's views. You don't have any more standing than the next guy.

'For one swallow does not make a summer, nor does one day; particularly after hip surgery and in the worst AFL midfield of all time.' - Aristotle

A full pre-season to build up strength through his core and uninhibited hips will do him wonders

I would have thought that GC would only be accepting picks due to their list reduction

I would rather take a punt in the draft than settle for the second best/safe(ish) option in Caddy. I think a lot of clubs would be happy to part with players equal to Caddy in ability for pick 13, but that's just my opinion.

Using pick 13 on someone who finished 19th in the BNF after playing every game is equally, if not more, flawed. Mitch Clark cost pick 12. We can do better.

ohhh yes niko. very nice. we're looking the goods to hold on to 4th spot