Adam The God

I said something like this 10+ years ago on Demonland, but the less Melbourne people involved in the CEOs chair and the FD, the better. I understand Nicho is well rated, but [censored], we're so prone to groupthink at our football club. Administration after administration.

If it were a choice between Leppitsch, Bruce or Simpson, I'd choose the unknown in Bruce. Would love Leppa as a line coach though, maybe the senior assistant to Bruce...

Lyon would also know. He's got the ear of a few.

It helps that their midfield and half back is stacked with good ball users...

I doubt they have. "Hi Josh, now I know we passed over you for Gary Pert, but would you be interested in putting your hand up again to steer this club?"

JUH was a free hit for the Bulldogs though, got a number one pick for a bag of crisps, and Lachie Hunter anyone...

I did wonder how long it'd be before Luke's name was proffered. I have a feeling Caro is just joining dots here, rather than leading with any real insight. I wouldn't be against Luke taking the role, although as @BDA says, I'd be wary given Luke has never made the top 4. He's made two GFs though, which makes him probably the greatest Bulldogs coach ever.

I don't think retaining players that want to go is a good enough reason for keeping Goody. Why are they trying to leave?

We're terrible moving the ball partly because the players aren't on the same wave length. In 2023 we didn't have Windsor, Lindsay, Langford or Kolt. All much better users of the footy than Viney, Oliver and Petracca.

Maybe, but had we kicked straight in 2023, it could be a very different story. Playing our old method, minus Trac and half fit Clarry, we lost to Port by 2 points (prelim finalist), GWS by 2 points (semi finalist) and by 5 points against the eventual Premiers in Brisbane after a soft free was paid to hand them the winning goal. Put Trac back in that team, a fitter Oliver (apparently not), allow our guys to play the contest game they've honed; add the ball use from Langford, Lindsay, Windsor and McVee; and exploit the greater pace on the list from Lindsay, Windsor and Kolt, and away we go. This is why I was buoyant going in 2025. I thought we'd play essentially the same game style with a greater emphasis on being able to score off turnover. We've gone away from this trying to play something that has clearly killed the instincts of the players, to the point where there is no identifiable brand or game style on display now and the players appear confused. We should return to contest, stoppage and defence. We should even consider playing a hybrid of the territory game. The next evolution of the game will be defensive and that is what we've built our success on and built our list for.

"Thanks for staying with us", is an odd sign off. I'm not sure what I think of that.

Is it Hinkley or is it Carr? Roos was "coach" in 2016, but Goody was essentially coaching then.

Very fair. And the fish bowl probably doesn't help.

.

We drafted Clarry and Trac and are now imploding, but I guess you're right. The leadership needs to be better next time.

Even if we could get him, Reid doesn't look good cultural fit for us...

Choco did this with Dusty at Richmond, I had always hoped he would do the same with Clarry. It appears, not so much.

And have the board say they were implicitly responsible? The board could have had PJ undertake the external review at the end of the last year. Instead they had Pert review himself.

The latest review was run by Pert who later... resigned. Ridiculous conflict of interest. Signed off on by the board.

But of course this isn't the board's fault. 🤦

As usual, anyone that doesn't play for Melbourne is great.

No, I blame the board. They installed Pert (a disaster) instead of those PJ put forward, and then allowed messy legal battles to play out over Goody's head for at least 12-18 months. And every club in the land has the same constraints vis a vis COVID, that's not a reasonable excuse. We got unlucky with Burgess wanting to move home. I think had we had him across 2022-2023 we'd have at least another flag, but the personnel inside the FD have clearly let standards plummet and continue to do so.

Brad joined the board in November 2020. He and the board have been asleep at the wheel. The FD report directly to the board. The board is accountable.

The fish rots from the head and your mate Green is front and centre.

It's pretty clear the review was a smokescreen. Deemocracy lobbied for an external review. The club didn't want to do one initially, but eventually bowed to this external pressure. Unfortunately, as the closed shop at board level remains, we got a tokenistic "external" review where Shand and Crowe were to restore harmony and team spirit. But has anyone heard from Shand and Crowe? Mentally, we went to water in Round 2. Green is a sycophant, his conversation with Clarry was all about the past, and nothing about Oliver's past 24 months, or the standards the club needs to set for the future. Green and the board need to take full responsibility and Smith needs to get the new CEO installed asap. Would any other club take 4-5 months to find a new CEO? I get we don't want just anyone, but our inability to land one should set off alarm bells with this administration. We need significant on and off field change over the next 6-9 months, and unfortunately I have no trust whatsoever in this board to put in place competent people.