Cheap Seats

Ahh Demonland Beautiful one day, perfect the next

I knew you liked my work.

Did you enjoy my work OTC last night?

Thanks for the laughs.

Any other commentators or anything elae you're upset about you feel like sharing? Or was that it?

Cool. See my poat above. Im not upset about rightful criticism. If you dont like listening to Garry i dont care.

No stress, it's all good. I got no issue with what you're saying but if we ever want to go for a flag we have to be better then that. And that's my interpretation of what Garry is saying. Happy to agree to disagree

Im not sure why people get so upset with Garry. He is paid to observe not barrack. He has an opinion on the game. Its still better then Huddo and the other peanuts. Regardless of if he over did the commentary or not, for the MFC to take the next level and become a really good side there are lots of fundermentals we still have to clean up. Bit like what Clarko says. You can be middle of the road or you can be elite. We are not elite.... the criticism is warranted.

Strange to assume it's just a coaching decision.

Offensively we have been inconsistent all year, defensively is worth keeping an eye on. I dont think we've let teams score more that 10 goals and through defence we've managed to stay in touch most of not all games (rd 1 is debatable). A huge improvement on last year defensively.

You must rate Adelaide

Yep agree on all fronts. Just wanted to add CP5 was out best creativley last week and made somw terrible decision tonight. Glad he slotted that one in the last. Kozzie and Bennell are rhe class we are crying out for. May is interesting, might be handy up Forward with t mac out? I am hopeful with time May will settle and not make as many mistakes. It sounds weird but May is still new.

Hats off to Jack tonight. Credit where credit is due.

Im not really invested in the opinions either way. Regardless if the opinion is right or wrong there is no need to be thst demeaning. Just my opinion

Way to beat down on an opinion. I guess leadership isnt your thing.

he should fit right in then really...

No we're not, it's as simple as that.

Thanks for contributing

It's about utilising the players strengths ots not a hard concept to grasp. Contested ball team (we were no.1 for a reason) less contests = worse team. The coach is one part on a team. If the players cant execute you dont have a lot of options. If you dont get the concept there is no point discussing it. You dont have to be a geniusto work out our players arent skillful.

And people still want to tell me 6 6 6 didnt change anythibg. It was all the coaches fault. Im not havibg a go at yoi WWW just making some observations. The "red zone" has worked during games but like was discussed we lack t her talent to execute right now. Either they play players who can execute and drop the onea who can't or change the plan. Something has to give. It will be interesting because if Goody cant fix it he will be gone.

So whats the right game plan then?

Not sure if serious or not. We'd still kick it to the opposition with bigs or smalls.

I'm verry well aware. If i get some time im going to post pics/vids of how pathetic we are. That Viney clearance you're mentioned in your point was embarrassing. He burnt T Mac and rainbowed the ball to the opposition. Ive been patient but enough is enough. They need to drop players who cant execute or follow team orders. When we moved fast we looked ok. But some players dont get it or cant because they're not good enough. I'm also pretty sure i didn't need Tim m Garry to tell me what i posted at half time. Turnovers are killing us and nothing is changing. But to be clear im not talking about all turnover, they will happen. Im saying punish players who can't hold possession or play the way the team wants. And im focusing on our high profile midd who are the leading cause

Im not disagreeing with you @DeeSpencer but i reckon i could also find multiple examples today of non ruahed kicks with the same results. And it's the same offenders all the time. We need a drastic change of tactics and one trick ponies who continue to butcher the ball should be dropped no matter how much they get it how much they're paid. We carry too many contested players who butcher the ball. Enough is enough

100% agree. There were times in the game where we took the game on but made mistakes and I can live with that. It's the first examples I can't. We laud Brayshaw on this site - he is another who gets the ball but butchers it constantly. I will get the clip but there was one instance he had time and space on the wing, rather then handballing to a running player to advantage he took on a kick to a 1 v 5 which rebounded for a goal. It is likely even if he handballed we'd have still turned it over but as a midfield group they are always going for the long open the game up kick rather than taking easy options and helping us hold the ball. We may not score but fudge me it will still has to be better then giving the ball to the opposition