layzie

For monetary reasons no but for selfish perfect world reasons I say boot it!

Which bump on Guy Mckenna was better?

Not a lot wrong with those predictions. I do feel the Giants will push the Cowboys and I actually wouldn't be surprised if the Panthers bottomed the NFC South. Mack will take out the sacks steaks. That's an absolute lock

Haha see you in Week 3!

With you there, ready to back their selection judgement 100% on this one. Would hate to be in the hot seat.

This made me giggle!

Fair enough, I'm expecting a few different viewpoints on this.

Total apples and oranges question, but taking all backstories into account who deserves to be in the side more right now Bugg or Watts?

This weeks selection is getting more nerve wracking by the day and could have plenty of implications. I'm leaning to the idea of Frost back in T-Mac up forward but not by a lot. If they decide to rest Viney I can deal with that. The guy has just got too much guts and teeth gritting ability, I would hate to think playing through it is causing potential future issues. I don't blame anyone for floating the idea of Watts straight back in. Even at 70% of what he's capable of he can make a difference but honestly it doesn't feel quite right. Short term sacrifice, long term result (hopefully), the time has come to know where we stand with Jack.

Still in the 'promising' category at this stage I'm afraid. And that's coming from someone who is a fan of his.

Richmond is the dream scenario for me. First final in 11 years, MCG, 80,000+ and also after that Anzac Eve pain a potential grudge match. Could not think of anything better. After that I'd take Port in Adelaide over Sydney in Syd by the stretch of the Hume Highway.

Anyone one would struggle with such an intermittent stop-start season like his. Really just hope he can get a clear run at it next year after the year from hell.

A part of me definitely wants him to feature again this year. I'm sure he's in the mix but it says more about our competition for spots right now.

Man I love that table. Been so handy

Oh yeah and "a power of work". That's a new one

It sounds like if he or any of those nancy boys are pi**ed off they should be pi**ed off with each other. I can say that I 'deserve' 20k more on my salary because I work damn hard and be 'pi**ed off' but that does not make it factually correct

If true then I'm pretty happy about that. Cam offers something pretty different and unpredictable in the ruck and can hold his own up forward.

Skype!

I like the guy's talent but we can't be a second chance city for cast offs who have bad work ethic anymore. The boards have been blowing up lately with our other guy in that category.

Yeah I'm with you. Bring Frost in, I was enjoying T-Mac back in the backline but our best bet is with him up front for Weid.

Yeah for sure. Even just for loose statements like your classic "Most Melbourne people would say that Jake Lever would be a valuable addition" line

A player like that would give us some leverage! Ok that's enough!

Yeah I'd expect the media people to peruse this forum.

Worth a shout. Definitely prefer Lever though

I do like the guy as well. He brings something to the table and its kind of nice to see a player for us with a little swagger. However an auto-in he is not, even before all that hoo hah he wasn't a walk up start by any stretch of the imagination. Have him in the mix by all means but he's gotta earn his spot again.