Sir Why You Little

Maybe..OMac was good in the finals. His confidence is rising

One should never recruit a Key Position player from WA if this trade becomes a reality. Hogan’s career is still in first gear... F.($&..k...

Check your spelling Mondè!!

Yes and Opposition Teams will target him hard now on the ground. A year of transition with Hogan would have been an interesting proposition

I know all that but he is a contracted player, who can assist the Weid in becoming a better forward for a year. I just get the feeling the Weid is still a touch green. Just my feelings...

Exactly.....

Still not happy that Hogan is 23 and being traded... I know all the permutations, but it is still wrong Josh Kennedy left Carlscum... the Weid better be committed to a long term career...

and we are counting on Weids being ready after 2 good games... it is certainly High Risk next year...

Yes and we lose a 23 year old contracted Key forward for a pretty poor deal...

So let’s try and win the flag in 2019. It may change his mind

Walk away. Hogan stays...

Would make it a fair deal

So a player back to the MFC becomes part of the deal? how strong is this? hope it is true....

The Weid is in for a huge preseason. I was hoping JH would hang with us for one more season as a transition but it seems that aint to be. The AFL lie is alive and thriving well

Gubby Allan negotiations...

Possibly. But Whorethorn do it every year. Very Shrewd club, i want the MFC to be similar sensible risk management

Sure. But it cost them nothing to find out... we traded Pick 4 for a busted Toumpas a few years back Cost us a lot...

Whorethorn have picked up 2 former Top 10 draft picks for basically nothing... They continue to be smart operators....

Whorethorn paid a future 4th rounder.... that’s the same as collecting him up from the nature strip with some hard rubbish...

Yes i know that bell came a day early

And we could get completely shafted. It may be a better idea to keep Hogan for 2019 and go after the flag...

If Bell ? has flown to Melbourne it will be to negotiate the Hogan Trade. I hope Mahoney stays strong on our requirements

There is a strong argument for slamming the door shut on Freo Last Friday night and renegotiating new tearms with GC. If we get blind sided and Freo get their key forward i will be in a foul mood

Pick 7 and extra picks could get it done, if we are still deadlocked. I just do not like all eggs in one basket. Rule 1 in how not to do trading business.

So what happens if May goes to Footscray whilst we offload Hogan? Plan C...? This is all taking far too long and has the potential to leave us in a very precarious position, which may be exactly how Freo are pushing this. We the MFC should be pushing them, as it is them who have no forwards. If May becomes a dog, we need Hogan for next year...