Demon3

You are old and the only people lacking intelligence is the geniuses at the club that went public with the no review line. You speak in riddles Binamn, and its really boring.

For the record, Oliver is not Thriving, Gus is treading water and Harmes has always had good skills, Take your ridiculous else where.

Mate, seriously, i cant be bothered. there you go.

For starters, this is a knock on the club, so just relax, and no i dont have stats, i have perfectly good eyes though that suggest he is a wreck with the ball in hand from about 30ms out and closer and its getting worse. I suppose you will take an alternate view just to be different?

Enlighten me binman please? Why would a team say they did not review a game that was an unmitigated disaster, They then open themselves up to severe criticism from others saying that they were derelict in there duties not to perform a review. It makes the club look weak, unorganised and unprofessional... which is a coincidence because thats what it appears like we have been for a majority of this year.

There is absolutely no reason though to lie about it.. why would you say we didn't review it if we did review it.. Its truly bizarre and the club has been nothing more than a mess since the PF loss.

Bumping this back on the agenda.. like we didnt review teh PF loss, it feels like Petracca has been allowed to get away with poor Set shot goal kicking for 3 years now. Is anyone addressing this... probably not because we lack that much professionalism its not funny.

Bailey Fritsch is shockingly out of form and if we didn't have such a big injury list he would be dropped, but again, he is played out of position, like Brayshaw is at the moment. Bailey should be High HF / Wing. Anyway this weeks changes should be minimal.. expecting Tim Smith out for Pruess, but if Smith is fit i would keep him in, its pretty amazing the bad run he has had. ANB might be crook from concussion, if so Corey Wagner in for him. Thats it, cannot, i repeat, cannot bring Jordan Lewis back in. this will test Goodwins resolve.. we dont need him in the side at all. not for any purpose, especially against a side as fleet footed as the Giants.

Lachy Reid, who is a mad Demon by the way.. just tweeted that Trac is in Perth, may have got earlier flight.

I agree, but it also might be a very bad game to debut in..

so no Garlett and Trac to go with Lewis, Melky and Hibbo. God speed Demons.. God speed.

Over to the mids to work as hard as they have all year. Going to be a test. Do we give up and concede or do we do what Richmond did in Perth and just go for it. Eagles are not flying by any stretch of the imagination.

yeah i admit he looked really sluggish.. but unless we know you have to assume he wasnt and was good to go.

Might be harsh, but go back and have a real good look at his game, just watch him.. i think you will find its borderline despicable.

Unless it comes out he has broken his leg, he should have made a better effort.

All fair points YB, i think he has had a so so year to be honest, his Centre Clearance attendances are down, so its different than last year. Its just my opinion, he had a great year but he has regressed and Pendlebury doesn't fumble.

it was good wasnt it, and as Bad as Oscar's lack of smarts were , Hore's were very good, read the play very well. Has become a really good player. The Vision of Oscar is what frustrates most of us the most.. no urgency at all, i don't care if he hurt himself getting tackled.. be better, be more desperate.. just perceived pressure can be very effective at times.

I reckon he is way off, and his game on Saturday night was despicable, it was full of fumbles, looked slow lacked care and had no purpose in his game. It seems though he is playing slightly different position, he has had less inside the square time than the other mids.. why would this be the case, why would a bloke who had a career year in the guys, be forced out of his domain. Its curious, could it be because we are trying to find a spot for Jones? it seems weird. one thing i do know a fumbly footballer is a liability and a player who is lacking confidence. Didnt think i would say that about Angus.

I really like Tim Smith, he does something that no other forward is doing at the moment, he can take a contested Mark. Lets be honest, he hasnt ever really had a good run at it.. I think he should play. So updated changes: OUT: Lewis (rested /inj) Hibbered (inj) Keilty (out) IN: Pruess, ANB, Smith.

Regardless of injury or not, i would hope Goodwin has the sense to rest Lewis, Perth is a big trip for a veteran. So i though the game was utterly disgusting on Saturday night with a fantastic ending, but we were horrible, in so may areas. Billy Stretch offers the team spread.. and thats it.. nothing else, will be very lucky to keep his place. I would like to give kudos to Frosty and Nathan Jones, i thought they were fantastic. Gawn and Oliver Huge in the last qtr. and Hunt's game was a classic case of even if you are not hitting the scoreboard, you can have a great impact. So Changes this week, not the game to bring a first gamer into in Perth. Baker has another good game in the 2s then get him in. OUT: Hibberd. Lewis IN: Pruess. ANB

26 years on air would suggest otherwise. Take it you didnt like it but it was far from one of the worst shows to ever make it on TV screens.

No Pruess for me..im not sure who comes out for Jack. Wagner was good i thought last week, maybe its Billy? he did provide a bit spread for us although he really adds nothing else to our team apart from that.

No doubt its going to be tough to win, even if we were in really good form, the Suns have shown they are a much better and harder side to play against. It does feel like they only have one real avenue to goal, so that will be the key, our defence to be really on and we can counter attack and score.

Lewis aint getting dropped..The last 2 weeks we have been so better defensively.. coincidence? im not sure but i think he must organise a pretty limited defense. For what its worth i believe he is totally done. but i dont think he is getting dropped.

I want to put this on the Agenda - I believe Christian Salem will be leading our BnF and is arguably in our top 3 most important players. He is flying under the radar but he has become a very very good footballer.