Chook

Did you hear? Scully's gone too, and Dean Bailey's been axed. He's the one who came after Daniher.

I think Russian's poor performances are getting under the radar. He's gone seriously downhill this year and last year.

Right. I think we had to, unless we wanted to pay him out.

I have noticed that too. Not a fan of Royal at all.

Bartram's selected on his effort. He was at one stage matched up against Dean Cox because he was the only one willing to do the work required to man up the forwards after yet another quick transition from the Eagles' defence. He'll continue to get games until people with better skills are prepared to do the work he does. Bail is similar, but he has more upside, more pace and slightly better skills than Barty.

Look, I agree. But we have bigger concerns than Jack Watts at the moment. I suppose he has the most upside, so he's copping the most criticism. I understand that, but we need to focus on identifying the players who have no future at Melbourne. Jack Watts is not one of those players.

Just a bit of push and shove from the Tiges. We're yet to see if it will pay off, but it's something the Melbourne players didn't show today when they were getting flogged.

Based solely on their performances this round and last round, I'd say Martin, Trengove, Watts, Magner from last week, and Clark, Bate and Jones from this week. Magner is the only one who performed well both weeks. Everyone else is either potential or has so far proven that they can't perform in this day and age.

I know of at least one demon who is a [censored].

Do you really think I'm satisfied with mediocrity? Four players played okay last week, and four this week. Jack Watts was one of them. Why consider delisting him when there's at least 26 players on our list who are performing worse than him.

Free agency might actually help sides like us, contrary to the belief of people like WYL.

Everyone bitching on Jack Watts needs to remember his performance last week. Don't be the typical reactionary supporter, to whom only the last week's game is of any relevance. Jack Watts wasn't very good today, but he was good last week. Obviously there's potential there, and anyone hoping for a Watts delisting is clearly not worth listening to.

The game has moved on and we have not. Run and carry is dead. Also, do not underestimate how bad Sydney were that day. That was probably their worst ever performance under Paul Roos. We kind of just got them on a good day.

Don't give up. There's entirely too much of that going on at the Demons right now.

I feel like assassinating Dean Bailey, Craig Cameron and Barry Prendergast for putting us in this mess. But that would be giving our senior players too little credit for the stunning role they've played in the complete and utter destruction of my beloved Demons.

6. Clark, for the goals he pulled out of his arse. He sure as hell can't pluck a thing out of the air. 5. Magner, for the hundreds of times he dove in for the ball, and for his disposal by foot, which was amongst the best in the side. 4. Jones, for the things he does every single week, but that nobody else in the side seems to want to emulate 3. Bate, for coming on and extracting the ball, running hard back and forward, and kicking it long and straight to targets. Contributed at least three goals in his limited time on the ground. 2. Dunn, for providing a bit of a forward option. Honestly though, he should have done more, as should everyone. 1. Howe, for giving us some leading options up the ground and for working hard back and forward most of the day. Again, made a hell of a lot of errors and goes the big leap too often.

OUT: Green, Macdonald, McKenzie, Sellar, Bennell IN: Tapscott, Moloney, Morton, Couch, Tynan Green is gawn; Macdonald is too slow, too short and his disposal is wretched; McKenzie can't dispose of the ball properly and is still not fit enough because of his injury; Sellar only came in to match it with the WCE talls; Bennell has no idea or willingness to get the ball Tapscott is hard at it; Moloney is still our best midfielder, and as long as he hasn't cracked the sads, and is one of the few senior players who has a shot of taking us forward; Morton is just a hail-mary, hope-he-shows-something selection; and Couch has had some good form of late; and Tynan should never have been dropped. Is Sylvia a chance of playing next round? If so, then he's straight in, perhaps for Colin Garland, who's been woeful all year.

No experiments from the coach again today. Is he aware that you can order positional changes as a head coach?

Another goal setup by Matty Bate - and yet he started as the sub today. Why?

Magner, Clark and Matthew Bate BOG for us. Everyone else needs a long hard look in a mirror. 1st gamer, pick-up from another club, and someone clearly so fed up with the Melbourne culture that he was screaming to get out last year. Everyone else is indoctrinated into the zombie-like fluff and chocolate (thanks WYL) outlook endemic to the MFC.

We already look better with Matthew Bate in the midfield. Clarky has kicked 5 goals, none of which have come from marks. That's an intictment on our midfield delivery.

Neeld not changing his positioning may be an attempt to instil his gameplan into the players. But by not moving his players around, he can't see what they can do. Throw Clark into the ruck, put Bate on for a whole game for once, put Garland up forward, put Frawley in the middle, put Jamar at full forward. Do something proactive. It's not all up to the players. They need to see that the coach is still trying things - that he still cares. But there's nothing. We may as well have a cadaver up in the coaches box.

This is Dean Bailey's doing (and the senior players). Mark Neeld has got a huge job ahead of him.

152

Another crumber's goal from Mitch Clark. He's been good, I suppose.