Chook

My judgment isn't based on just today's game. I wonder if anyone can ever criticise a sub, since the excuse can always be made that the game is almost always decided already when the sub comes in.

He certainly has.

Super sub? More like SUPER DUD! For God's sake drop this country footballer please Mr Neeld.

6 Jones, who is far and away our best player, perhaps outside of Clark 5 Sylvia, who only needs a hypnotist to tell him he's playing Richmond every week 4 Blease, who is going to be an absolute jet 3 Nicholson, whose kicking can really let him down 2 Jordie McKenzie, who I hope is going to be okay after his big knock 1 Spencer, who uses his big body better than Jamar does around the ground.

Probably a few rich ones, too.

According to most Melbourne supporters, he should never be picked again. Patience, young grasshoppers.

"Tigers not home yet" - Dwayne Russell Er . . . yeah, Dwayne. I'm pretty sure they are.

Dunn is a FORWARD only!!! Get him out of the backline ffs!

I reckon Jake Spencer's really shown a fair bit today. I like him.

How could there be 4 Richmond players free inside 50 after the ball's been in there for about 5 minutes? Unbelievable. Also. At least the umpires' idiotic goal errors are even now. Atrocious!

But the worst part of it is that on this occasion, the video review WAS conclusive. If we had someone brave in the review box instead of some faceless chicken, we would have had the right call, because that was as clear as day! I don't ever [censored] about the umpiring, but that was atrocious.

What the [censored] is the point of a video review system if they're just going to make the wrong decision anyway? #burndownaflhouse

I have a feeling you're not being honest.

They're the same one.

If it's not his fault he's limited, then whose fault is it? His mother? Dean Bailey? God?

People are still holding on to his 5 goals against Collingwood and his 18 tackles inside forward 50 (or whatever insane number it was). I wish he was still doing those kinds of things, but I don't think his fitness is anywhere near what it needs to be for those kind of results to happen.

Actually, I loved him because he kicked lots of goals for the Melbourne Football Club. He could have beaten baby seals in his free time and I still would have loved him.

Of course Moloney remains for another week. God knows why.

What about that Viney kid? I've heard he's pretty good.

He could be better. I also notice that he will ask a question, and then make little grunts of agreement while the interviewee is talking. I understand he's trying to sound agreeable and enthusiastic, but I'm listening to the interview for the interviewee, not for Robbo! He should be silent while the other bloke is talking.

It must have been last year or the year before that every time I saw him he seemed to be tearing teams a new one in the forward line. He's exactly what we need gathering the crumbs at Mitch Clark's feet.

I hear they made a pretty good book out of it too.

Spread too thin, you say? Sort of stretched, like butter scraped over too much bread. I need a holiday - a very long holiday.

Holy moly what an insensitive and idiotic post.

I'm glad everyone now sees what I've been seeing in Moloney since round 1: Nothing. Maybe he'll finally get dropped this week. One game against Brisbane too late, but oh well.