Chook

We have basically a two person injury list and yet I'd give anything to have Dawes and Clark available to play. Does that say something about human nature? Are we that hard to satisfy?

As I said when this story first broke, not all arguments are bad.

How much confidence do you need in order to say you won't come last? Not much I hope.

We won't win the spoon anyway, so there's your extra team.

Basically exactly what I and others have been saying all along. It's the players who are responsible for the good and bad performances we put in on the field.

What are the odds of nine different teams' planes crashing this year? Figure that out and you'll have deduced the odds of us making the finals.

I think what we did for Toumpas was just perfect. We let him know exactly how far he has to go to match it with the pace and difficulty of AFL-level footy, without just giving him game after game in hopes that he'd simply click. His second game was better than his first, and after he went backward in his third game, we took him out of the fire and let him cool off for a bit. Perfect.

Come on. That was not "behind play." It was not a disgrace. It was simply an undisciplined mistake. He left the ground before the kick took place and hit the guy a little late. He deserves what he got, but don't beat it up into anything more than it is. You're entitled to your opinion, but by god is it a shitty opinion.

Mark Neeld.

Unfortunately it's not an illegal supplement. To my eternal annoyance, it's wholly sanctioned.

I watched it again too and he was just as poor as I remember.

So let's just give it up then, huh?

Watch the replay. Our defensive zone absolutely befuddled the GWS players in at least the first term. That's a Neeld initiative, and it really came in handy. Too bad our players couldn't keep it up in Q2 and Q3.

Really? I thought he was older than that.

Harry Taylor doesn't have that much longer in the game, 'rjay.'

If Tom McDonald can improve his disposal, he could become the best centre-half back in the league. That's a BIG "if", though.

We should stick Max Gawn at full forward and bring in Spencer to play the second ruck role.

Johnstone was far more damaging than I've ever seen Watts be.

The great thing about Jeremy Howe this year is that he has dramatically improved his goal-kicking. Ive gone from knowing he'd miss to being almost certain he'll kick 'em. But don't tell the Neeld haters. They think no one has improved under his tenure.

What's hopeless? That we don't want him to get injured again and again?

How could you not have Michael Evans in your top six?

The only thing we can do for Jack Watts is remind him that he is not necessarily guaranteed a spot on an AFL list. Putting him in the VFL for a little while might remind him of that fact.

How do you figure? It's the players who play poorly. It's the players who play well. It's all them.

Both, because that's how it goes when you're at this stage of development.

Why? Love of the Club. Love of the Game. Love for a Challenge. Why does anyone do anything like this? It's certainly not for money.