-
Posts
4,806 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
4
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Store
Everything posted by Graeme Yeats' Mullet
-
I was a bit sad to see Frost leave the Dees, but his butchering of exit kicks from defense is horrendous
-
Yep, I think you're right But without the 2 rovers goals he kicked I reckon he'd be struggling
-
Just watched the presser Thought his first answer about Weid was pretty straight bat and wouldn't have read much into it Then some reporter asked 3 more questions somewhat in awe pf Weid and Goodwin gave similar agreeing but dead bat type responses. The third question a few mins later, when the reporter drew attention back to Weid was just uncomfortable...
-
Brown was being double teamed, scragged all night, and still managed to get to impact lots of contests Weid was regularly behind and not quite there, really needs to hit more contests hard and smash packs. Then a few more marks are likely to stick
-
That shouldn't be our benchmark, it right for us to set higher standards
-
Was that called play on by ump for not-15? He paused and seemed to be waved on
-
Spot on He was a bystander at too many contests
-
While he kicked 3, that's all he did. 1 mark, no tackles He was behind a lot, and could barely jump at the ball, hardly impacted a contest I think he'll be lucky to keep his spot
-
My 3 word player analysis V Richmond
Graeme Yeats' Mullet replied to joeboy's topic in Melbourne Demons
Was pretty sloppy -
He was very good Copped a bit of the brunt of heavy pressure as the Tiges smashed our fwd movement with extra mem behind ball, and good tackling But when we freed up, ANB got good ball, and found targets
-
GAMEDAY: Rd 06 vs Richmond
Graeme Yeats' Mullet replied to Whispering_Jack's topic in Melbourne Demons
Starting the day with a short sharp replay of GF, 10mins to go 3rd Qrt Update: that hit the spot... as did the coffee- 634 replies
-
- 10
-
Is Jackson in doubt? Heard secondhand that Stevo reported rumours...
-
Ezzackly Embarrassing to 16 teams to hear they are 2nd on ladder
-
Horrendous 50 3 or 4 others let go already
-
Another Arms Out... No free kick
-
First free kick Preuss - Arms Out.... no 50
-
-
Dunno, mine was a genuine question We played most games early in weekend... (incl. Wed) so every possibility he's match fit
-
Don't mind it either, but not all that confident Weid will step up Who is medi-sub? Has Bedford been able to run around for Casey in recent weeks, or has he missed out on playing a few games? If he's missed out, then he should go back to Casey and someone else get a run as Sub Tomlinson is back strength with a bit of wing flex? Otherwise Melksham utility?
-
The very, very contentious 50 for Dissent Rule
Graeme Yeats' Mullet replied to picket fence's topic in Melbourne Demons
Great P15S take on The Front Bar -
The very, very contentious 50 for Dissent Rule
Graeme Yeats' Mullet replied to picket fence's topic in Melbourne Demons
Yep as a neutral spectator it was a great game to watch and the only downside was horrible umpiring late in game -
The very, very contentious 50 for Dissent Rule
Graeme Yeats' Mullet replied to picket fence's topic in Melbourne Demons
Agree Consistency is far more important than where you set the threshold for the decision to be paid Problem is, when you set the threshold really low the individual interpretation of dissent (which has element of subjectivity/feelings) will vary a lot - leading to worse inconsistency -
The very, very contentious 50 for Dissent Rule
Graeme Yeats' Mullet replied to picket fence's topic in Melbourne Demons
Didnt AFL say decisions paid were correct, and there had been some "slippage" being decisions not paid (that should have been) How can Scott then say it can be up to umpires interpretation? It can't be both wrong (missed decisions) amd up to umpires to decide... Inconsistency is what infuriates people... this is designed for inconsistency, irrespective of whether you like the underlying rule or not. -
The very, very contentious 50 for Dissent Rule
Graeme Yeats' Mullet replied to picket fence's topic in Melbourne Demons
The key issue is why are 90% (guesstimate, but would appear to be some large majority) of what AFL insists is breach of umpire dissent rules not being penalised just 5 rounds into season? "Slippage" (reported by Jon Ralph) can't account for that big an error, it must be that the rule simply doesn't make sense to the umpires, (who are supposedly receiving the dissent) -
The very, very contentious 50 for Dissent Rule
Graeme Yeats' Mullet replied to picket fence's topic in Melbourne Demons
Hilarious 😂