Previously known as LITD.

Goody brainfade to make him sub in such a big game. And then we had to play him.

Tmac holds because the cupboard is empty. How many times this year when bought back in has he failed? All of them. Laurie was a huge error from Goody. Maybe if he came on as fresh legs in the last 15 mins ok. But we were exposed to what the sub is really for and a kid with 5 games played a whole qf and no surprises only touched the ball 5 times. Not his fault. He's just starting. Hardly like for like for Gus though. Chandler should have been dropped 6 games ago. I can only surmise Spargo wasn't smashing it at Casey. Don't know enough about AMW but Grundy will come in as last man standing for Jvr. We lack depth. Anyone for Salem?

The young five gamer in Laurie was hardly like for like. He had five disposals. I'd say it cost us the game and given that Gus smashed Carlton last time we met, may cost us another.

I'm in the same camp. I'm sure his intent to hurt was there. I was just positing that he probably didn't mean the ko. Not because he's not a mug but because he wouldn't want to be suspended. Then again I wouldnt put it past him. Claimed remorse but didn't say I'm sorry that hurt him. It was all about saving his own hide rather than caring about the bloke he.. " loved to bits" Pleaser. Maybe he worked this whole smother ruse out some time ago. He's finished this year and rightly so.

I wish they had retaliated more. Fair and square though. Well done Viney.

Good post. Also Gus has missed two finals. At a bare minimum Maynard must too.

Yep. Maynard came out pumped. He wanted to make a statement. I'm sure he didn't mean to ko someone ( only because he wouldn't want a suspension) but he was clearly trying to rough someone up.

We looked soft. I think the pies thought we were. And maybe they were right. Gus lying on the turf and no pies players given decent jumper punches wasn't a good look. Aplogies to Jack Viney.

He even looks guilty. He's a grub. Four weeks is lucky. Good if he misses a granny. What about Gus. He's missed a qf which we may have won with him playing. And next weeks final. That's on the positive side. Could have lasting consequences. How on earth did Maynard think he would land? The ground will break his fall? He knew full well he would collide with Gus. It's not just the act but the trying to save his hide with this subterfuge of " footy act".

Given Laurie had 5 disposals, would we have won if Gus wasn't knocked out? It's clearly more likely.

The Pies did do well flooding our backline although our slow entries did help them. It was pretty crowded in there most of the time.

https://youtu.be/uhiCFdWeQfA?feature=shared

Last man standing. He gets to play in a Mfc final.

What a tool to say that. Was listening to Maynard interview after the whack and thought it strange how he was talking about it being a footy act and that he loved Gus to bits yet didn't hear him say I hope he's OK.

Tommo for Tmac.

Gobsmacked after 5 average games, he was sub in a Qf. And had to play the whole game.

Gus was fantastic last time we played Carlton. Just saying.

Gus played very well and had 31 possies. Bloody hell, I'm angry about that hit.

Ten years since Carlton have played finals. Big deal. Go Swans.

Umps average. Actually very poor.

Umps average.

Maybe stopping the Carlton hype is our consolation prize.

Well that's good news . Tx.

And here comes the rain. Footy really sucks this year.

Anyone else perplexed about a young five gamer given the gig of Sub by Goody? Had a shocker and not just the last quarter. Not like he tore those 5 games apart either.