Demons11

I think he’ll be fine. I’m sure he is working on things in the 2’s and will be back in the side by years end. Just because a player gets dropped doesn’t mean he will leave or be traded. The kid just needs to build his confidence back up.

I have a sneaking suspicion the AFL will appeal this decision.

Hawkins will be happy

Completely different, these players pushed the umpire. It wasn’t friendly.

Malice is not an issue. You can’t intentionally touch an umpire, regardless of the force. As stated this feeds down to lower levels and even a slight intentional touch should be punished. Greg Williams got 9 weeks for pushing an umpire. In the lower levels, kids are umpired by kids and therefore a strong message needs to be upheld.

Why shouldn’t he go??? He pulled the umpire back. Regardless how soft, you can’t touch an umpire on purpose

If they didn’t think it was intentional, they would have fined him already. I assume they also would have got the umpires opinion before laying the charge.

Even this was the case, you can’t touch the umpire. 1 week.

What a shame

Where did you see this?

100% agree. The dribble that comes out on here sometimes is ridiculous.

I think Rowe will get dropped, they will bring Weitering in.

I didn’t even write this??

So you’re hoping one of our players, plays badly so they can drop him?? This is an awesome attitude to our team.

I half agree with this. Spargo will be stiff to lose his spot but Garlett is so dangerous and with so many opportunities I agree he will give us more. Spargo is in his first year and over the next couple of years he will hopefully develop into this very dangerous forward pocket player. I don’t agree on the Weed front, he has been in the system a few years now and I think key talls need to be given time to develop in the seniors. With an eye on the now and the long term I think this will pay huge benefits. O Mac is a perfect example of this.

From the Casey reports I read, Garlett was good today. I think he replaces Spargo.

I never said but they are playing completely different roles.

So he has been poor, then plays well and you want to drop him. makes sense

He is captain of the footy club and an absolute bull. There is no point keeping him in the 2’s

Some Game commentary would be most appreciated.

Viney is straight in next week. Spargo didn’t do much yesterday, a week off and then back to Casey

Hopefully Garlett plays well today. Back against the Blues next week. Spargo out i’d say. He has had a taste

He only just signed 3 months ago.

I think it’s there only option. Goodwin talked up the Weed after the game and Viney won’t play ANB’s half forward role. Tyson is an inside mid who has not been overly effective and still makes lots of mistakes

Easy this week. Out: Tyson In: Viney