Jibroni

Is it just me or does Tim Gossage need punch to the nose?

But if Lever did not get injured we most likely take Collingwoods spot last week and be singing Mahoneys praises. Lever was the right player to trade for at the time.

He also thought Hawthorn were the only side that could beat Richmond, what a knobhead!

Did he have any to start with??

Straight swap for Josh’s Kelly would do me.

Well, maybe this has been a complete waste of time after all.

Fair call but I’m not giving up Pick 6 for S May alone as he is simply not worth it IMO. If we are going to have a sustained period of success we still need to build the list, hopefully the FA will come naturally.

Rather keep the pick and draft Rozee and make a play for May next year. Would can use a later pick to get KK,.

One has to be top 5 otherwise why bother.

I think it is the later unfortunately. If we do not get at least one top 5 pick and another first I will be disappointed.

That's the part that worries me the most!

Sad day as I was hoping he would stay, the kid has serious talent.

Surely Luke Darcy you would not go on National TV and declare he is gone without a solid source.

Yes I would be shock if the players/coaching staff did not know his intentions for 2019 and beyond.

Surprised Cats would not be showing interest.

Melksham, Pederson, Hibberd and even Frost have worked out pretty well? I understand your point but perhaps look at each individual in isolation and not the collective.

Concerned about his concussion issues, but can play. Would be similar value to Kent I would have thought?

Didn't know that.

Im predicting tomorrow that Hogan will announce that he is staying and this thread will get to 100 pages.

Yes, he has skills, strong but can be bit of a hot head. I would not be giving up a top 10 pick without May + something in return.

The more this pans out the more I want Jesse to stay (at the right price!).

That's a long straw to bow isn't it?

And you will have to find a new profile pic as well DL? Im still 50/50 on trading him.

Like his attitude but realistically if Hunt can have a big preseason there will be at least 2 blokes capable of playing his position. Depth player for me.

So would I hence I would want S May with a 2nd rounder in return. Otherwise no deal and move on.