WERRIDEE

Young offensive unit? What the hell are you talking about? The defence could coach themselves May, Lever and Salem at the peak of their powers, but in saying that he should be a coach of defence he was a defender. He's out of his league as a forwards coach.

The last paragraph is complete and utter rubbish. I’m not wrong the coaching landscape is a joke due to people like Chaplin.

They have devalued coaching by letting anyone coach. Chaplin has no idea on forward line coaching Fritsch must laugh when he tells him what to do. He’s teaching the kids wrong. It’s no coincidence that Fritsch form has gone down the toilet since he has coached. Must go at seasons end.

rubbish . The way coaching is going I could coach. Can't play forward can't coach forward, Never trust a male gynecologist.

Brisbane, Gold Coast and Hawthorn have forwards as a coach 3 of the better teams. Says it all really. Xavier Clarke was a forward also.

Chaplin has been around forever and is coaching the most embarrassing line. I did say most coaches not all.

Yes I'm dropping McDonald, Howes, Woewodin and Bowey. Lever and Jefferson are injured. C.Windsor, May and Johnson come straight into the side from injury and suspension. Hore, Campbell and Langford have been promoted.

We should go in with a bit of optimism after getting a draw against Norf. Gold Coast usually field a very strong VFL team so they will be hard to beat. The Casey players that I was really impressed with were Bonner who had it over 30 times, Baldi who led by example and youngster Kirkwood-Scott. The Melbourne listed players I was impressed with were Campbell, Langford and Hore. Possible team. B: Smith, Adams, Bonner HB: Howes, McDonald, Bowey C: Billings, Laurie, K.Windsor HF: Kirkwood-Scott, Fullerton, Brown F: Yze, Melksham, Lewis FOLL: Verrall, Woewodin, Baldi IC: Sestan, Cross, Lual, Mentha, Craven

That's one quality player we can get and it wouldn't surprise me if we done a salary cap dump on Oliver.

Goodwin and Chaplin should go. Jones\Radford and Bassett are safe. Lets look at the list shall we May - Stays van Rooyen - Stays Salem - trade him to Richmond where they need experince. McVee - Stays Petracca - Stays but if he wants to go he can go. Windsor - Stays Viney - Stays Lever - Stays Spargo - goes if he does stay I don't have any problems with it. Turner - Stays Gawn - Stays Tholstup - Stays Oliver - Personally I think he goes but if he stays I'm fine with it. Billings - Goes Langdon - Stays Laurie - I think he's contracted but he goes IMO trade him for nothing he was a top 20 pick. Bowey - Goes in a trade someone will take him. Melksham - Goes Retires Langford - Stays Lindsay - Stays Jefferson - Stays Howes - Goes delist McAdam - Retire if you know what's good for you Rivers - Stays McDonald - Goes Retires Adams - Stays Hore - Delist Verrall - Delist or stays don't care. Campbell - Stays Sharp - Stays Fritsch - Stays but I'd be shopping him around. Sparrow - Stays Fullerton - Delist Petty - Stays Pickett - Stays but if he wants to go go Chandler - Stays Sestan - Delist Mentha - Stays Woewodin - Delist Brown - Delist Johnson -Stays Henderson - Stays Kentfield - Delist Moniz-Wakefield - Stays Culley - Stays for now have to see more of him. That's 16 players out of the club not including. The 5 possibles. Changes will be made to the list as well as the coaching staff.

I beg to differ. We still haven't replaced Brayshaw who was on good coin.

He come back through the 2's with his interrupted summer.

I forecast 6 changes this week Out: McDonald, Howes, Bowey, Woewodin, Jefferson (inj), Lever (inj) In: May, Windsor, Langford, Hore, Johnson, Campbell B: Hore, May, Rivers HB: Salem, Petty, Windsor C: Langdon, Petracca, Lindsay HF: Chandler, Johnson, Sparrow F: Fritsch, van Rooyen, Spargo FOLL: Gawn, Oliver, Viney IC: Campbell, Sharp, Langford, Henderson SUB: Turner

Why is it on one or the other? Why can't it be both? If the message isn't getting across to the players maybe the coaches should find a job. It will be on the players now. Woewodin and Howes had enough chances to hold a spot in the team haven't done it. McDonald time to retire won't be around next year. Bowey could be finding another home at the end of the year. They are 4 players that should be dropped and there maybe more.

That hurts again. Lucky for you I have posted my worst 22 coaches. B: Neeld, Neeld, Neeld HB: Neeld, Neeld, Neeld C: Bailey, Bailey, Bailey HF: Chaplin, Chaplin, Chaplin F: Chaplin, Chaplin, Chaplin FOLL: Bailey, Bailey, Bailey IC: Stafford, Stafford, Stafford, Stafford SUB: Stafford

I've had it with Clayton he does nothing with ball. I left him out of the team to make a statement. Langford in the middle for mine because Langdon has been disappointing for a while now. We just have no one playing the football that we know they can play.

Carlton and Freo.

I'm hurt by that comment. I'm sure demonlanders only come on here to see my best 22's

A little bit of column a and column b. In other words Chaplin has his say but Goodwin would have the final say.

Been blammed

Nice joke

rubbish

He like Petty isn't a forward and he is suffering because it especially when you consider Howes gets a game down back talk about a player that won't make it. He and Laurie have showed nothing and I'm losing patience with Bowey and Woewodin.

Ben King is an absolute star. Max hasn't come on unfortunately I think he will show it against us on the weekend especially if May doesn't play. Ridiculous to say this is make or break for Jefferson he has at least to 2027 to find his feet.

The boot studder is a disgrace couldn't get the grass out of their stops.