WERRIDEE

If you can't handle facts I can't help you! Take another look at the Sparrow draft and tell me if that was a good draft? This is worse that's why we got out it to get 2 picks in last years draft. The top 20 last year would all be in the top 2 to 3 this year. This draft is no good no matter which way you look at it. The talent coming out Victoria is weak except for the first 2 picks in the draft who are Victorians. There is a little bit of talent coming out of SA but not much.

That is where we will be if we rebuild because Tassie will take all the picks leaving us with no picks just like 2012 again. We could finish higher with a healthy Trac, Clarry, Gawn and recruit Flanders and Miochek.

Look at Gawn look at Dangerfield 30 is the new 25. Petracca could play on for another 5 years. Flanders could be another bust in 5 years. We shouldn't be looking at Petracca's age.

The silence is deafening. Which is a shame I wish he would just come out and say I'm going nowhere.

I realize there is a shift to rebuilding but it's the wrong time Tassie are coming they will take all the draft picks. It's not the right time if we are still on the bottom then good luck moving up the ladder. Be careful what you wish for.

Yes it is. This draft is horrible it goes 2 players deep West Coast will be licking thier lips the rest will get ordinary players. I take you back to the draft when Sparrow and Jordon got drafted. It was a horribly weak draft but Taylor did well to secure them considering what came before them and what came after them. This draft is worse the worst of all time. I trust Taylor to do his best if there is no talent there there is no talent there. I don't want draft picks in the worst draft of all time I want players. Gold Coast have said Humphrey, Read and Walter are off limits. I say fair enough with Humphrey he's a generational player but Read and Walter no way. You have to give Read, Walter and Flanders or you are not getting Petracca minimum. You can thrown in Rosas for nothing and we'll throw in pick 23 for more draft capitol.

What's absurd is your trades it doesn't benefit us at all. To say Petracca doesn't make a difference is just stupid. He's our second best player. It doesn't bother me because thankfully your not making the decisions. My concern is Lamb. He's proven that he just wants to get deals done even if that don't benefit us like giving away second rounders for Frost and McAdam. I trust Taylor I don't trust Lamb.

Her pressure is pretty good but she can't kick. It's tight for spots. Someone is going to miss out.

Trac's not at his best yet. If he gets back to his best along with Oliver and if we pick up Flanders and Miochek we could make the 8. Without him we are rebuilding which means pain especially with Tassie coming in I don't think we can afford to rebuild.

It's not win win win. It's not a win for us what picks are we going to get from Adelaide? They have none? When has Flanders become a star like Trac? I fear we could win the spoon the way the Trac trade is going.

We had a good win against West Coast with Zanker on fire early, but we would be disappointed with our last quarter out pressured and out scored against. We have to put the pressure on for all 4 quarters, not just when we feel like it. My possible team B: Colvin, Gillard HB: Goldrick, S.Taylor, Chaplin C: McNamara, Hanks, Paxman HF: Fitzsimon, Harris, Bannan F: Gall, Zanker FOLL: Pearce, Hore, Heath IC: O'Hehir, Pisano, Wortherspoon, D.Taylor, Campbell EMERG: Mahony, Ebert, Rigoni

Ridley has said he's going nowhere. That's all Trac has to do and it stops. Why he wants it to go on and on is beyond me.

If you are saying it's too much you have rocks in your head. Flanders is an average player pick 6 is an average pick. 2 average players for Trac get real. We should want more. Throw in Read or Walter. Humphrey would be a stretch he's a star.

The silence is deafening when it comes to Petracca he done the same thing last year and it done him no favors. I don't know why does it it's stupid. Just come out and say are you staying or going. Oliver came out and said he's staying heard nothing since. Petracca has bad management it damaged him last year and it could damage him this year.

Who have the saints recruited? De Koning ordinary footballer ridiculously overpaid. Marshall is a better footballer one of the most baffling decisions of all time to recruit De Koning. Ryan should retire. Silvagni struggles to get a game for Carltank. OOOHHH SCARY SAINTS! Trust me there going nowhere.

The disrespect for Trac is unbelievable but if you say a bad word about Clarry you're walking on egg shells I just don't get it.

No votes in the last six to 7 weeks wishful thinking. He has serious issues that can't be wished away by a magic wand. We can't carry that burden. I'm not even worried about what picks we get for him or players we could get for him I think if we can get a club to at least pay half his wage then off you go Clarry best of luck at your new club. Petracca on the other hand I would want the world for him.

Rubbish. Got smashed in the midfield by Brisbane. You need 6 to 8 players running through the midfield they only have Rowell, Anderson and Miller the rest are ordinary including Flanders. He could be a good pick up he's got youth on his side, but I wouldn't put my house on it, he could very well be a bust.

Are you talking about Oliver wouldn't surprise me. Trac got 16 GUN

You sir are a clown

I'd hate to tell you but those B&F were rigged back then. The coaches delibrately didn't give votes Flower because they wanted an unknown to win because Flower was always the favorite. They struggled to find new faces to win it that's why they gave Fowler 2 or 3 B&F's

People who want picks for Petracca are kidding themselves. The draft goes 2 players deep Duursma and Duff-Tyler then there is a massive drop in class. This draft could be the worst of all time. Pick 6 for Gold Coast is an average pick while Adelaide's pick 14 is an ordinary pick. They should give us those picks for nothing because the chances getting a quality player are remote. That's why we need 2 quality players from either Gold Coast or Adelaide because Petracca is worth 2 quality players.

After you said Petracca is a keeper I thought you would make more sense than this. Comparing 2012 at our absolute worst to now ridiculous, but if you take Petracca out of the side we could be at our worst. Who is going to keep up the slack if he goes? 2nd year players in Lindsay and Langford? Petracca's not in the top 50 players he'd be close. The top 50 players on average would be your top 2 or 3 players at the club. People say he had an ordinary year. How can you say that? He finished ahead of a player who had a great year in Pickett who was All Australian. That's not easy to do. The player they should be getting rid of is Oliver but no one wants him. He's half the player Petracca is.

Your joking aren't you? I'd take a B&F anyday of the week ahead of an umpired Brownlow. The B&F is done by coaches. The Brownlow is only set up for pure midfielders. If it wasn't Gawn would have won a brownlow by now. I can't see Gawn getting more than 15 and Pickett and Petracca having more than 10 we had a poor year.

You are soft. As I've already said I prey Tim.Lamb isn't like you. If he wants to leave then we get compensated handsomly or he stays as simple as that. If Lamb chooses some of the scenarios that are on here then Tim.Lamb should get the sack. He's lucky not to get the sack anyway but that would be the final straw.