DubDee

Headline on AFL.com is a spirited bombers challenge and they lost by 44 points. That’s how bad they are

I think the point may be - we are so worried about losing him yet we don’t consider him best 22 Nevertheless he is a good young player who had a down year and hope he stays

Sometimes easy runs can be the worst prep for finals. hopefully it is the case For me it is Lions then daylight then Crows records against the top 9 is telling

See you tomorrow I might not be very good at gardening but my rates are very high

This has to be one of the most boring seasons of AFL ever There is not one decent game left this round. Odds of $17 and even $21! Our game probably the best chance of an upset. maybe port. Might do some gardening

All i’m saying is there have been 9 players making their demon debuts this year which is factually correct.

would be insanity to hire Hird in any capacity

Howes and T Mac was good down back and Petty dominated fwd makes sense

*9 Demon debutants #HalfThe18

9th debutant in a year with not many injuries #NotARebuild

If Max did his a serious injury, we’d have no mature 1st ruck cover Pretty obvious need I would have thought

I know we need some cheering up this week so here you go Will be 21 years next month. Grab some popcorn and enjoy friday night footy!

Lost at selection again Goody

I feel hungry Although I don’t deal with my emotions, I just make bad jokes, so who knows?

After tax, Simon will only have half of that 🤣

I’m not fully against Buckley. I think he is still hungry for a flag and would have learned a lot from his 9 years at the Pies

certainly was impressive to rebuild the list and make a GF. A list that didn't need rebuilding but nevertheless. However, by our (eg Goodys) standards he would not have gotten the chance. After 2 years of no finals with a talented list, he would have got the sack. Interesting to compare the 2 careers. Goody actually has the better finals record too.

I honestly thought if there’s one person happy today it would be you Goody is gone On to the next thing already? at least be happy for a few days

Add him to list of maligned played that are bagged on here. Then go well at another club and people wonder why we let him go He is 100% keep for me

Yep, let’s go there. Pies 2012 list was stacked and Bucks rebuilt it under the guise of poor culture

I would say with 15 premiership players in the 22 then yes. In Collingwoods case they were young and highly touted as the dynasty - more than most. He underperformed supremely and if not a pies legend would have been sacked years earlier

What about not finishing higher than 11th for four years straight with a premiership list?

Goodwin and Buckley have fairly similar coaching records Goody has the better finals record and obviously Bucks took over a premiership team Vs Goodwin a young up and coming team Bucks missed finals for 4 years with a very good list. I'm far from convinced

Buckley has hidden his feelings well over the past 30 years

I give it a solid 6 months before a ‘Is Horse the right guy’ thread starts if he gets the job