samcantstandya

I am also sick of our players tackling and then falling to the ground and it's in the back & when we throw a hand out and give them an around the neck, or we are near the boundary and we toe pock it for a free. We must rate as either the dumbest players in the league or we don't practice our tackling.

Dawes' first 3 kicks were all unbelievably putrid. He dribbled a pass towards a leading Hogan, then he went across half forward and kicked it to the opposition instead of going towards goal, then he runs into goal and dribbles it wide from less than 20m. I always cringe when we recruit players from other sides dating back to the Ben Hollands of this world. Clubs usually dress up their trades and we get lumped with them.

I've always liked him since he committed to the club as opposed to a former number one who didn't.

I didn't get there till halfway through 3rd, I saw us kick 2 goals. It's like we are a soccer team we just can't score = boring.

I cringed when I first heard we were keen 2 get Dawes, just like years ago when we traded pick 20 for Ben Holland.

Thanks that made me laugh.

Why won't our forwards chase and keep the ball in our forward 50? Are they lazy, prima donnas or not accountable?

So is banging your head against a brick wall.

So who is Melbourne's????? Or is it that we don't have one or we don't practice. We don't kick enough goals and we should. They are pro footballers who can't execute the most important skill to kick goals. U can defend till the cows come home but u need to be in front.

We must be the worst side in the league when it comes to kicking 4 goal. I'm tired of Dawes not being a reliable goal kicker. We need either to get rid of all the crap kicks or spend up and get a kicking coach. I can't stand hearing how bad a kick McDonald is either. Don't they practice their technique. It's not good enough, they either improve or don't get games. It's football afterall how u get 2 AFL standard & not be a good kick. It's got 2 stop. Danhier kicks 5 straight & we kick 7 18. I'm so glad I didn't go 2day. I get angry supporting this club sometimes.It's not like we didn't know they'd come out all guns blazing. Please let's not gift games to players who don't give a flying......

Casboult is a crap kick.

The longer the delay the more likely that one or both are goneski especially if Howe was offered big money from GWS. Shame about Howe is that he is one of the few on our list who the kids like to follow.

They are both NQR. Especially Bail, he hasn't got it. Too many times he's missed easy chest marks and goals from set shots. He is very slow to react and knock on loose balls. He's got pace but maybe he choose wrong sporting path maybe athletics was more his game.

We need to delist both Bail & M Jones they cost us with their poor skills. We will never improve while we have list cloggers like them, Terlich, Jordie, Riley, etc.....

Judd in his prime over Hodge.

Definitely

Beggars belief doesn't it out with 2 NQR's & in with 2 more. I agree with u we have 2 stop playing guys like M Jones, Bail because they can run & Mckenzie & Terlich because they try hard.

We need to drop both Bail & M Jones because when the heat is on they can't cut it. Both dropped easy chest marks because they were bracing themselves for contact. Compare them to Brayshaw yes they both can run, but both are poor kicks. I'm over players that can run but are crap footballers. We have 2 many NQR'S in our squad. We have to delist them ASAP and go for kids who can kick and are smart footballers.

Bail had 5 possessions and missed a gettable goal at a crucial time. He should be dropped because his performance was poor.

How did Bail do his job. He was ineffectual at best. He had 5 disposals and missed a very gettable goal at the end of the 3rd.

When Bail had that set shot at the end of the last quarter I knew he was going to shank it. He just can't impose himself I've seen it 2 many times. Whereas Garlett & Vince had very difficult shots that that they nailed. Different class Bail delist material.

I can't fathom how Bail gets a game.

Spencer has had 2 games & isn't cutting it. We need to bring Gawn in and stick fat with him.

Jamar contributes nada around the ground and his taps go nowhere.

I only noticed 2 of his kicks the first was a running kick for goal in space 40m from members flank that he shanked knee height to nowhere and the second in defence members wing across goal to a contest that we lost. I'm no fan. He is a liability. Ok he got a goal in the 4th q 20m dead in front. I want us to move on from the Bails, M Joneses, Mckenzies etc.........