Trades that worked and those that didnt

[WonnaJurah 5]

i just looking up at past trades we did in the draft and interesting to see results

Traded Got

Matthew Bishop Micheal Clark

Troy Longmuir Brad Green

Patrrick Wiggins Steven Powell

Paul Medhurst Peter Vardy

Jason Laycock Chris Heffernan

Alex Gilmour Ben Holland

Darren Jolly Lynden Dunn

justin sherman Jamie BAKER(WHO)

Danny Meyer Brent Moloney

Woey Belly

quite a few good trade offs there

[Ausyid 0]

Unlucky for us with the Sherman trade.

Anyone seen that video about Fremantle and their trade history and who they've lost out on because of bad recruiting.

Quite humorous.

[WonnaJurah 5]

Unlucky for us with the Sherman trade.

Anyone seen that video about Fremantle and their trade history and who they've lost out on because of bad recruiting.

Quite humorous.

is it on youtube?

sam mitchell

luke hodge

Andrew Mcleod hehe

[Jaded No More 68,974]

I had a bit of a thing for Michael Clark, but man he was a dud!

Would you rather have kept pick 20, or get Ben Holland?

Keep in mind that we could have chosen someone good with pick 20, since we are not Richmond and we do know how to draft.

Vardy was a great get, but he was too old and too injured. A shame because he was a gun right up to his retirement. Medhurst is a troll!

[WonnaJurah 5]

I had a bit of a thing for Michael Clark, but man he was a dud!

Would you rather have kept pick 20, or get Ben Holland?

Keep in mind that we could have chosen someone good with pick 20, since we are not Richmond and we do know how to draft.

Vardy was a great get, but he was too old and too injured. A shame because he was a gun right up to his retirement. Medhurst is a troll!

the number 20 pick , currently plays for Brighton ,never got an afl game

think holland better

[Big Kev 373]

I had a bit of a thing for Michael Clark, but man he was a dud!

Would you rather have kept pick 20, or get Ben Holland?

Keep in mind that we could have chosen someone good with pick 20, since we are not Richmond and we do know how to draft.

Vardy was a great get, but he was too old and too injured. A shame because he was a gun right up to his retirement. Medhurst is a troll!

How can Vardy be a great get? In your own words he was too old and too injured. He may have been a good gamble that didn't really pay off. Even though he showed glimpses of his former brilliance (against Freo when he won the game off his own boot for one).

[Ausyid 0]

is it on youtube?

sam mitchell

luke hodge

Andrew Mcleod hehe

Don't think it's on youtube. IIRC it was a flash video. Wish i knew where to find it. I must have seen it 3 years ago.

[WonnaJurah 5]

How can Vardy be a great get? In your own words he was too old and too injured. He may have been a good gamble that didn't really pay off. Even though he showed glimpses of his former brilliance (against Freo when he won the game off his own boot for one).

wasnt as bad as picking up cook and moorcroft

[Jaded No More 68,974]

How can Vardy be a great get? In your own words he was too old and too injured. He may have been a good gamble that didn't really pay off. Even though he showed glimpses of his former brilliance (against Freo when he won the game off his own boot for one).

We obviously didn't think he was injured, and his age was a good fit at the time as we thought we were a chance to win a flag.

From memory, we didn't pay a whole lot to get him, and he gave us good service. His time with us was short, but I really enjoyed having him in our forward line. IMO our forward line was at its most productive when he was on the field. I wish we could find a 'crumber' like him again, big, aggressive, and with a magical boot.

We absolutely lack forward pressure, especially when Davey is running around in the midfield.

[Cactus 2]

Don't think it's on youtube. IIRC it was a flash video. Wish i knew where to find it. I must have seen it 3 years ago.

it was www.matera.com.au/historyofdockers

but this has sadly expired.... well thats what it said when i typed it in

[youami 54]

the number 20 pick somehow got to west coast, and is sam butler. if you do dreamteam pick this bloke up next year he is a possession machine but has been injured for the last few years. butler will be a very very good player and there is room in the eagles midfield now.

regarding what id prefer, we keep getting an extra year out of big ben holland. however, im of the opinion that any trade that doesnt result in a premiership is a wasted trade.

[Ausyid 0]

it was www.matera.com.au/historyofdockers

but this has sadly expired.... well thats what it said when i typed it in

[The Cold Hard Truth 0]

Holland was traded for pick 20 to Richmond.

Which was subsequently on-traded to Western Bulldgos from Richmond (along with pick 6) for Nathan Brown.

Bulldogs then on-traded pick 20 to Geelong for Peter Street.

Geelong then on-traded pick 20 to West Coast for David Haynes.

West Coast eventually drafted Sam Butler (not Gilmour who went pick 21 to Richmond)

So its actually Holland - Sam Butler

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

Vardy was a great get, but he was too old and too injured. A shame because he was a gun right up to his retirement.

How can Vardy be a great get? In your own words he was too old and too injured. He may have been a good gamble that didn't really pay off. Even though he showed glimpses of his former brilliance (against Freo when he won the game off his own boot for one).

When we picked up Vardy, he had a sensational year, and was still a fantastic player for subsequent years, if a bit injury ridden. Consider for a moment what our forward line would be like with him in it now. We could REALLY use a dashing, marking, leading, crumbing forward who can kick them from impossible angles from 55 out. Remember the goal he kicked that started that unbelievable run in the 2002 Semi against Adelaide? He did that regularly. Sylvia is a similar player I reckon, that's how highly I rated Vardy.

I remember about 10 rounds into Pickett's stay I thought we had another great trade on our hands (and to some degree we did), as it turned out he didn;t stick around. For mine, Vardy has been our best trade in recent years (not including the draft picks we traded for, eg Belly...)

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

wasnt as bad as picking up cook and moorcroft

Wasnt Cook a PSD pick up? Either way he kicked six in one game then did his knee in the next. He was hardly the worst we have had.

Moorcroft was a dud if ever there was one.

For mine, Vardy has been our best trade in recent years (not including the draft picks we traded for, eg Belly...)

Rather damming assessment of MFC if it were true.

We obviously didn't think he was injured, and his age was a good fit at the time as we thought we were a chance to win a flag.

From memory, we didn't pay a whole lot to get him, and he gave us good service. His time with us was short, but I really enjoyed having him in our forward line. IMO our forward line was at its most productive when he was on the field. I wish we could find a 'crumber' like him again, big, aggressive, and with a magical boot.

We absolutely lack forward pressure, especially when Davey is running around in the midfield.

He was injury riddled and gave us good service!

We got just under one good year out of him. Injuries limited his output. He was hardly a great pickup.

[deanox 10,033]

Holland was traded for pick 20 to Richmond.

Which was subsequently on-traded to Western Bulldgos from Richmond (along with pick 6) for Nathan Brown.

Bulldogs then on-traded pick 20 to Geelong for Peter Street.

Geelong then on-traded pick 20 to West Coast for David Haynes.

West Coast eventually drafted Sam Butler (not Gilmour who went pick 21 to Richmond)

So its actually Holland - Sam Butler

well done. if you search for it i started a thread about that (or posted in a thread about that years draft (i cant remember), but i worked out who had played more games, kicked goals etc we've done the best to date, with holland performing reasonably compared to even brown (considering brown also cost pick 6) due to his injury. and sam butler is the other one who hasnt played hardly at all. given our situation at the time, picking up holland was a great get, we needed some extra depth KPP and we got one who has provided good service...

[pantaloons 2,019]

The best trade I can remember Melbourne pulling off involved the acquisition of Jeff Farmer for Phil Gilbert in one of the most comically lopsided deals in history. One of the few bigger steals than that was Adelaide slaughtering us with a Nathan Bassett for Matthew Collins and Brent Williams combination.

[jacey 333]

the number 20 pick somehow got to west coast, and is sam butler. if you do dreamteam pick this bloke up next year he is a possession machine but has been injured for the last few years. butler will be a very very good player and there is room in the eagles midfield now.

So true.

Sam Butler is a very very good player. I'll have him over Ben Holland any day.

Beau Waters and Sam Butler were the two players coming through fast last year.

Jump on him Dreamteam next year.

[Oxxx 0]

Best one ever was Phil Gilbert for Jeff Farmer.