Which deal is better for the Dees???

[shimmo 0]

As just reported on the news, and who knows what's true and what's not. I'm just guaging everyones thoughts of what they think is a better deal. First one is:

Johnstonee to Brisbane

Wood to Collingwood

Pick and Rhys Shaw to the Dees

Second one:

Or Pick 20 and a player from eagles. Which brings me to the last question what player would you want along with pick 20 from the eagles?

[Red and Blue Flame 142]

i'd do the pick 14 and rhys shaw deal

but if it was pick 20 and a player from eagles, i'd take someone like a Jaymie Graham

[Diablo 1]

As just reported on the news, and who knows what's true and what's not. I'm just guaging everyones thoughts of what they think is a better deal. First one is:

Johnstonee to Brisbane

Wood to Collingwood

Pick and Rhys Shaw to the Dees

Second one:

Or Pick 20 and a player from eagles. Which brings me to the last question what player would you want along with pick 20 from the eagles?

I'm skeptical about the WC one being legitimate, but probably the Collingwood one. I really do not like Rhyce Shaw, but in spite of the way he looks, he actually seems to be a decent bloke.

As for the question, Pick 20 and Beau Waters and no less.

[Springfield Isotopes 0]

St kilda want a ruckmen and have pick 9 why not convice brisbane to deal with them, the sainters might even throw someone like Mqualter (however u spell it) into the deal aswell.

[Adzman 2,086]

From the eagles?

I would take Beau Waters+pick 20 for trapper.

Or if they were game, Darren Glass+pick 20 for Trapper.

Doubt they would move either players, but they can both defend and god knows we need some bloody defenders!

[Red and Blue Flame 142]

Jaymie Graham is far more realistic in that deal...and hes a a tall backman..what we want..plus we get pick 20

[Yencks 8]

yess this sounds good...id take pick 20 and Ben Mckinley from WC for Trapper for sure and i thinks thats very realistic.... u listening CAC?

[Diablo 1]

From the eagles?

I would take Beau Waters+pick 20 for trapper.

Or if they were game, Darren Glass+pick 20 for Trapper.

Doubt they would move either players, but they can both defend and god knows we need some bloody defenders!

Glass? Good thing Hannabal isn't around or he'd be wondering what substance your abusing.

Beau Waters would be good, I reckon. He's got a bit of mongrel about him, he's big, he's young, and he's got some skills. I would take Pick 20 + Waters over Pick 14 and Rhyce Shaw.

[Red and Blue Flame 142]

they wouldnt trade beau waters!!!geez get realistic people

[Diablo 1]

they wouldnt trade beau waters!!!geez get realistic people

Dare to dream, Mini-Chief, dare to dream.

Unfortunately we can't play WC and Brisbane off against each other very easily, because of the Brisbane deal being 3-way. Otherwise I reckon if WC were genuinely interested, we could snag Waters.