This years Best and Fairest should be scrapped

Why? Because Bruce would be leading?

Someone is going to win it by default

Someone is going to win it by default

You believe that noone in our team has done their best in the fairest manner possible to win matches for us?

This years Best and Fairest should be scrapped

Your comments just get more outrageous. Some people are doing their best you know, obviously if everyone in the team was playing their best we couldnt be at the bottom of the ladder. Most people in the team are trying thats what the medal is about. What sort of supporter are you?

Tip for the end of the season has to be Rivers. i think 100% of melbourne supporters appreciate how good he really is, and how he and whelan provide poise in a backline that desperately needs it. I also am amazed at how he leaves his opponent at just the right time to intercept the kick. He becomes an extra player when doing this. Also Jones for a second year player was great on the weekend, and most people around me marvelled at his endeavour and mostly sound decision making. Finally Petterd if he continues this form looks very good. Just great to see a rookie with such calm and confidence.

This years Best and Fairest should be scrapped

Honestly YM, that really is just silly.

And there is nothing default about it.

Losing (and we will win sooner or later) doesn't mean that there was no-one working their ass to try and win.

And losing doesn't mean that they (and right now Bell, Bruce, Rivers, Miller and Jones would be in the top few) shouldn't get some recognition of that work.

Good grief.

if only 'wheels' had been on the team. now i am remarkarbly biased towards this man, but i really reckon he's sensational. rated by the club too, he often always misses multiple matches a year but still rates highly in the B and F. i hope he can get back fit and back to his best, would help us out immensely

Bruce would be leading by a short mile.

I would like to see Newton get his chance but who ever gets dropped will be stiff. (Ironic saying that when we are 0-6)

Millers being good in previous weeks and deserves his spot. Maybe Pickett, Sylvia, Warnock.

It would be Bruce considereing he's performed fairly consistently and hasn't missed a game. Rivers has been terrific when he's played, I think we take for granted how good Rivers is.

Someone is going to win it by default

Brock could probably win it in half a season of football but unfortunately( iknow he has a broken bone at the moment ) i think his career is going to be dogged by soft tissue injuries.