Dees to get 5 Rising Star Nominations

[Guest The Boss]

I like Paul Johnson, and I hope he stays on next year.

One thing Bail doesn't add to the side=Goals!

I would add more, but you told me to keep it clean.

[Jaded No More 68,867]

I like Paul Johnson, and I hope he stays on next year.

One thing Bail doesn't add to the side=Goals!

Rohan Bail has a higher goal-per-game average than Paul Johnson. PJ has only kicked 19 goals in his entire career, yet he is apparently a greater Demon than the guy in number 11 who won a Brownlow

Oh what's that? you don't know what you're talking about? I'm shocked.

Edited July 28, 2010 by Jaded

[Guest The Boss]

Rohan Bail has a higher goal-per-game average than Paul Johnson. PJ has only kicked 19 goals in his entire career, yet he is apparently a greater Demon than the guy in number 11 who won a Brownlow

Oh what's that? you don't know what you're talking about? I'm shocked.

And while we're comparing a midfielder with the second fiddle ruckman, I would like to point that PJ gets more hitouts than Bail.

Anyone can use stats to prove a point.

[Eth 4]

And while we're comparing a midfielder with the second fiddle ruckman, I would like to point that PJ gets more hitouts than Bail.

Anyone can use stats to prove a point.

Okay, I will.

http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/ft_player_compare?tid1=12&pid1=527&tid2=12&pid2=3170&type=A&fid1=S&fid2=S

Bail is better.

[H_T 3,043]

One thing Bail doesn't add to the side=Goals!

So far of the players you have mentioned in your posts - Scully, McKenzie, Jetta. And what they add to their respective sides. ie. getting noticed... what they bring to the side, etc.

Well let's look at their respective goal tally's compared to that of Bail. Just for interests sake..

Player........Career Games.......Career Goals....Average goals/game.

Rohan Bail............6.....................3.........Avg.= 0.50 goals per game

Tom Scully............16..................4.........Avg.= 0.25 goals per game

Jordie McKenzie....17...................2.........Avg.= 0.12 goals per game

Lewis Jetta...........13...................0.........Avg.= 0.00 goals per game

Bail already adds more than you think.

What else do you have ? Please add more, by all means.

Anyone can use stats to prove a point.

[Guest The Boss]

Juice Newton is a better forward than Jack Watts. He averages more goals.

Juice: 23 games, 30 goals, average=1.3043

Joke Watts: 13 games, 9 goals, average=0.6923

[Eth 4]

Juice Newton is a better forward than Jack Watts. He averages more goals.

Juice: 23 games, 30 goals, average=1.3043

Joke Watts: 13 games, 9 goals, average=0.6923

Isn't Newton 26? Great games tally

[H_T 3,043]

Juice Newton is a better forward than Jack Watts. He averages more goals.

Juice: 23 games, 30 goals, average=1.3043

Joke Watts: 13 games, 9 goals, average=0.6923

I'm quite certain Juice had not spent as much time up field as what Watts has shown to date. Yet you've had a go at Jaded comparing PJ to a midfielder...

Let us also see how many games/goals Watts has next to his name after 5 years in the system.

Your argument(s) resemble swiss cheese.

[Guest The Boss]

They both spend time at CHF, so at least I am comparing players at the same position.

[e25 5]

HT, you know they're not arguments.

I would have expected better from you.

Didn't your parents teach you not to poke an idiot with a stick?

[H_T 3,043]

HT, you know they're not arguments.

I would have expected better from you.

Didn't your parents teach you not to poke an idiot with a stick?

No. It was always a snake.

Let's move on from this....whatever it is...

I hope Jordie gets a nomination anyway.

[Old Gregg 1]

Don't feed the troll...