KEEP BROCK

[Guest Cougar Magic]

McLean will be a very good player next season and will be back to his best once he gets a full pre-season. So if the cheats knock back the deal its not bad thing.

He wasn't touted future captain for nothing.

[Binmans PA 26,745]

No, thanks.

[RedsoxMan 144]

Only an academic question, the deal is done !!

[Guest Cougar Magic]

No, thanks.

pick 11 is weak in this years draft and is probably more like pick 21, that is not good compensation for a number five pick

[WonnaJurah 5]

pass as well.Pick 11 is great thanks

[Guest Cougar Magic]

from my understanding the deal is not done because carlton are asking for more

[two sheds jackson 3]

I wasn't keen on the McLean trade when it was put forward and I'm still tentative about it now, but to say that pick 21 is worth pick 11 in this years draft is just pure hyperbole. Sure, it's compromised with age restrictions, but come on.

[Freak 100]

totally agree with the original post. People that are happy with this trade are idiots. Lets have a look at pick 11 in the past:

Andreis Everitt (2006, pick 11): no impact to date

Shaun Higgins (2005, pick 11) : Gun

Adam Thomson (2004, pick 11): Dud

Beau Waters (2003, pick11): injury prone.

Winderlich(2002, pick 11): Good player

Richard Cole (2001, pick 11): Dud

Trent Sporn (2000, pick 11): Dud

With a weaker draft this year, we can't expect to get as good a player as above.

It's amazing how quickly people turn off Mclean because of an injury riddled season. Just like those people that were off Sylvia. Where are those people now? WHERE ARE YOU! own up to being wrong you flogs.

[Seinfeld 40]

He's gone to Vegas with players from Carlton for their end of season trip.....so i don't think he will staying at the Dees.....

[Rogue 585]

Use an existing thread.