Rubbish post, lets just turn all our players to stoppers, who many players in your starting 18 can you play as stoppers and to be honest Dunn has done 3 good jobs. If we play Petterd, Bartram, Mcdonald and bring Grimes in as well thats 4 players that will be better at this role than Dunn.

McDonald's on his last legs - I'd be shocked if he got more than one extra season - so lets discount him.

I think it's too early to say that all the guys you've listed are in our starting 18 - let alone 22 - but assuming they all play, I'm not sure why you'd pigeon-hole Grimes and Petterd as run-with players.

That leaves us with Bartram and Dunn, and you don't only play two defensive players in your team. I could envisage Bartram playing down back, and he was pretty good at giving us a target when breaking from defence. That'd leave Dunn with the midfield tagging role.

Whilst you do need a couple of stoppers at your disposal there are times when its more fun to say "what the heck" and drink the whole bottle!

I am looking foward to see how Dunn hopefully goes on Goodes this week. He has absolutely torched us in recent years and we have struggled to find a match up for him, using everyone from Godders to Bruce. Dunn with his size and speed should be an ideal match up for him.