Brocky Bashers stand up ...

[Jaded No More 68,867]

This is the first game he has had an impact on the game. I have no doubt he worked hard in the other games. Notwithstanding his age, he has done it tough this year and has battled to keep his head above water.

What do you consider having an impact on the game?

12th in the league in contested possessions? 5th in the league for disposals? 17th in the league in first possessions? 6th in the league for clearances?

Why is it so difficult for you to say anything truly positive about anyone who plays for our club? It won't make you seem soft you know

Just accept that he's having a good season, but that no matter how well he's playing, he cannot win games on his own. Yesterday he finally received the support of 21 other players and we won. No player is capable of beating a team of 22 on their own, and to expect that is completely unrealistic.

By the way, for someone who struggles with a tag, Brock's not really having trouble finding the ball is he?

[Eastie Boyz 0]

he's only 22 no one his age gets the best taggers like he does

Judd at WC, Murphy at Carlton, Stanton at the Dons . . .

Anyway, regardless of that he has to learn to deal with a tag or else every week you'll be saying "tagged out again" in the 3 word review every week

[Jerry Lundergard 420]

Judd at WC, Murphy at Carlton, Stanton at the Dons . . .

Anyway, regardless of that he has to learn to deal with a tag or else every week you'll be saying "tagged out again" in the 3 word review every week

Out of those three you just mentioned, Judd is the only one who you can say actually can shake a tag and he is considered an all time great, so i am not sure what you point is there.

Are you just pointing that there are other 22 year old who get the No.1 tag? Or are you trying to say others get the tag and still perform, so Brock should too?

[Eastie Boyz 0]

Just ones that have been tagged

[kramer 0]

I think you forget that it was Fremantle they played against.

If he plays a good game against Hawthorn and Geelong I'll take notice

and Miller as well...

[jacey 333]

Out of those three you just mentioned, Judd is the only one who you can say actually can shake a tag and he is considered an all time great, so i am not sure what you point is there.

Are you just pointing that there are other 22 year old who get the No.1 tag? Or are you trying to say others get the tag and still perform, so Brock should too?

Bang. right on the money. If you want to mount an argument, you gotta do better then Stanton and Murphy. (Judd's just a freak)

I've watched Stanton very closely as he's in my SC/DT and he's struggled to be effective being numero uno. Brock has definitely outplayed him.

Marc Murphy's had a slashing year but Judd and Stevens have being one and 2. How did he go last year as number one.

Brock has being solid to excellent for most of the year. Brock, Jones need support. Jmac has to an extent but not too many reliable sources after that.

[Rogue 585]

The second half v Geelong is one example that suggests McLean needs to learn how to beat a tag - there were many examples last year. This week shows that this is an issue for Jones too. At other Clubs these guys might not be getting a tag at their age/experience level, and while they have time to learn how to cope with a tag, TJ struggled all career. As individuals, and a team, our midfielders need to learn how to play while being tagged.

Bang. right on the money. If you want to mount an argument, you gotta do better then Stanton and Murphy. (Judd's just a freak)

Eastie Boyz was not arguing that they performed while tagging, simply replying to bjc, who said that no one else of McLean's age gets the #1 tag...

[Rogue 585]

I still think his lack of both speed and awareness is a huge problem. Obviously he is a very good player, but if he cannot improve those two key deficiencies in his game he is never going to be the superstar we all thought he might become. He also might become a worthwhile trade.

In other news, I heard a whisper at the game that Lynden Dunn is extremely unhappy at the Melbourne FC and will ask to be traded at the end of the year or go into the preseason draft. Apparently his contract expires at years end. I heard this only as a rumour and it holds no credence with me, however I thought I would put it out there to find out if anyone else has heard anything similar. I for one am a huge fan of his and believe he will be our best player in a couple of years.

What was your source? Did they suggest reasons for his unhappiness?

I don't think he's going to be a superstar, but it'd be disappointing to lose him (for nothing).