Grimseyisgod

Okay so in order im going to rank who id like

1. Goddard

2. Wellingham

3. Caddy

4. Boak

5. Embley

6. Toy

7. Tippett

In regards to Tippett, yes i think we should have a good crack at him as i really rate Tippett, him and Mitch could become the most 2 unstoppable forces of the AFL

yeah i obviously mean in defence... Rivers leaving though would leave a huge whole than and i would like Josh Toy to replace him there.

I still believe that we need one more forward though and some gun midfielder.

I reckon the best out of all the young players though are Josh Caddy and Josh Toy, Josh Toy would fit right in especially if we lose Rivers.

Josh Caddy and Jack Viney would be a delicious prospect lining up with each other alongside Trenners,Jones,Sylvia and Grimsey

i reckon that we should make a huge play for Caddy..

These are the ones I would be interested in. Top 10 in order of preference:

1. Nick dal Santo

2. Josh Caddy

3. Travis Boak.

4. Travis Tuck.

5. Chris Knight

6. Mark Nicoski

7. Brendan Goddard (but we aren't going to get him)

8. Travis Cloke 

9. Clinton Young

10. Danyle Pearce

I guess maybe we could have Young at 6 instead of Nicoski. I love Goddard but I can't see him coming to Melbourne 

Wellingham would be nice. Montagna out of question as well as lenny.

We arent picking up cloke i dont believe after what Needly said.

so far:

Wellingham, Caddy, NickyDal, Kurt Tippett would be pretty good.

Boak but i think thats unlikely, i would have loved Mackay but he resigned today.

What about Chance Bateman?

Benny Jacobs would be great.. would work well with Watts, both fellow Brighton Grammar boys.

Adyn Kennedy for North Melbourne just signed, thats a pity

I do not think Sylvia should be traded, but Luke Parker would be a great pickup, much like Caddy.

We better do something this year because this year we have a good window to pickup players

* Key position forward.

* Small crumbing forward

* Inside midfielder & inside/outside midfielder

* Rebounding defender

Key position forward: Cloke would be amazing to get.

Small crumbing forward: dont need one in my opinion, develop jetta and maybe tapscott could play a multi role at Melbourne

Inside midfielder & inside/outside midfielder: Boak (but i dont think we will even get close to getting him, Montagna, Hayes maybe, stanton as a restricted agent could be really good as i rate Stanton, Salopek,SHANE TUCK IS A STAR, matt rosa, Josh Caddy

rebounding defender: Clinton Young, Mckay, Pearce

but most of all the players that would suit melbourne best are Cloke, Montagna, Roa and Young and caddy

ok so maybe i overstated categoric. But Melbourne will not use pick 3 or 4 for him

One recruiter this week described Viney as a ''second half of the first round'' player - as in pick No.10 to No.18.

GWS could ruin Melbourne's Jack Viney draft plans

"we may not be prepared to use a high up first round pick on Viney" Mark Neeld.

this is off the age.

The age also goes on to say.

The demons were not adamant that Viney would be worth the high first round pick and that by some recruiters Viney is a second half of first round pick.

So you who called me a n00b can be quite because you have no idea what you are talking about. We both different links so don't just attack me.

Both Shannon Byrne and Jarrard Moore would be useless pickups.

Josh Caddy:

He has flare, very tough at the footy with alot of grunt. Alot like Sylvia

Im sorry but the person that said that it hasnt been said, should probably go and listen to Mark Neeld talk before he goes on these forums and makes comments. You're an absolute shmuck for trying to contradict people when you dont have any idea what you are talking about.

Melbourne WILL NOT pick up Viney with pick 4.

It has been categorically said

Yes!

I would love Josh Caddy

Montagna would be great, like supreme pickup.

If Sylvia goes I would be so angry, possibly the best player to walk through Melbourne's door right now.

Sylvia is a class player and i dont think that Sylvia had any discipline is his game. Colin was only getting over an injury in the first 9 rounds of the season.

It would be a shame if Rivers were to leave Melbourne because he is actually a pretty good player, but we would get a pretty good pick up for him.

Koby Stevens from WCE would be handy too. he's a tough mid who just can't crack into their strong midfield and he would get greater opportunity if he came to us!

You're right about he could be ok, but we have a "war chest" for a reason, to pick up guns and i have watched him in his 2 games that he's played and doesnt like look a gun, he likes that he could be an ok player

I think Cloke could be okay especially with Howe and Mitch Clarke supporting him.

Clinton Young looms as a good pick up for Melbourne if we can get him.

Lenny Hayes is a maybe only because of his age.

I'd pay for Caddy as i really really rate him.

I completely disagree. I am not sure if you have watched the TAC cup or not but Nathan Hvorat as an example shows more class than Viney and is very similar in the way they play just way more polished.

Viney is NOT in the top 5 players in this draft

Personally, if we have to pick up Viney for a 1st round draft pick say pick 4 ish.. its not worth getting him at all.

I think he has potential to be a superstar but there are so many players that are just like him, especially because

this years draft is superdraft and i think that there could be 3 or 4 "vineys" and maybe even better than him.

For a second round pick it would be unbelievable to get Viney and 2 other picks at 3 and 4

I don't want Melbourne to pick up just for the sake of picking up, we could use picks instead to develop.

So who do you guys think would be a good pickup or pickups