Grimseyisgod

dont want him, dont rate him.

I actually dont really rate Cloke either because when things are tough and at Melbourne they are always tough.. he wouldnt perform

Danyle Pearce would be alrightt as will clinton young but young is better.

Pearce had a great season.. just doesnt shine as well as others may think because hes in a horrible team.

hed be great

McDonald Frawley Strauss

Grimes Rivers Garland

Trengove Sylvia Pearce

Howe Cloke Watts

Blease Clark Byrnes

Jamar Jones Viney

Interchange: McKenzie, Tapscott, Pick 3, pick 13. Maybe Taggert and Fitzpatrick can show something.

look youve got an ok team there, but not a premiership winning one.

my best lineup would show

B: T.Mcdonald Frawley Rivers

HB: Grimes Garland C.Young (Hawks)

M: Trengove Wellingham Blease

HB: Howe Watts Sylvia

F: Tapscott Clark Brynes

Foll: Jamar Jones Viney

Int: Knights, Mckenzie, Pick 3 sub: Jetta (still think he fits in somehow)

No stkilda players worth a look there. Hahaha that post by Lace Out, that is amazing.. so true..

Gaff is a gun and i reckon pick 4 and bate would be perfect for him

You have to realise we were never getting boak. Mackay is unlucky but dont worry just because a player isnt a free agent doesnt mean we canst trade to get them

We would be so dumb to trade Jamar, he is more than an asset to Melbourne.

As for the westcoast trade it looks good, but they wont accept it. They can Have Bennell for free though!

Dont want Shannon Brynes.

Should seriously look at getting Wellingham and Young

Whoever we get will sit around injured for a year and then go home or go to jail most likely .

I really dont care about individuals anymore.

I want 20 games a year out of a recruit.

With SOME good games.

Thats all.

although you make some good points, i believe Jurrah had something to offer Melbourne. I think that Melbournes situation is alot worse than we all think due to the vast number of changes and players we need to come back and to get into the club. Viney will take 3 years before he can really start destroying and the same with our other draft picks.

I seriously hope our pickups from other clubs really impact us, as much as Mitch Clark. I reckon we need 5 mature aged players or players from other clubs. Chris Knights, Clinton Young, Goddard, Andrew Embley and i really like the look of Daniel Pearce so he could be a good trade with Moloney in it. Than there is sharrod wellingham where we will have to give up a pick probably and stefan Martin.

ohh well, Its for the best!

I dont believe Melbourne can even trade Jurrah, thats what i heard maybe im wrong.

Viney will go father sun 2nd round no doubt

Port Adelaide will want a good pick for him, no doubt.. i reckon we should push for second round draft pick.

Look i know there are heaps of young players around, like josh toy.

But we should look at some older players. like 2 year olds

Jacobs could be good, Id love Clinton Young, Knights, Riskaaaaaaaaaaa

My only issue with Goddard is that he's a angry player, but not in a good way.. Goddard will be tough to play with if we are a little down, i saw that with him and the saints at the start of last year

Isn't a Goddard type at Carlton. Don't see why he'd be any better at Melbourne.

He was a goddard type all of last year...i believe hed fit in really well with Jack Watts. Peoople are underrating Gibbs

Pick 3 - Jimmy Toumpas

Pick 4 - Jesse Hogan

Pick 13 - Ben Kennedy

2nd Round - Jack Viney

3rd Round - Jacob Ballard

4th Round - Jake Neade

5th Round - Daniel Nicholson upgrade

Rookie - Sam Dwyer

Rookie - Luke Tynan

Trade In - Koby Stevens

Trade In - Scott Gumbleton

Trade In - Sharrod Wellingham

I agreed with everybody up until Scott Gumbleton, Gumby is a no no for me

if we got andrew gaff i cry of happinness

plus each of those team has at least 1 STAR who averages a high amount of possies.

yeah sure, 13 teams dont?

i want to win a premiership

Collingwood do, Hwks do, Geelong have Selwood, Adelaide have thompson

Mackay wants to stay at adelaide, he isnt coming to Melbourne. BUt id be happy with wellingham.

infact id be happy with anyone as long as we dont get gumby or use picks 3 or 4

yes but i believe there are players who fit into Viney's category in this draft but they have more class.

Nathan Hvorat anyone?

Well, I'm sorry but you're actually wrong. Getting the ball has been one of the major issues.

There is not one player right now this year that has been good enough to rack up 28+ disposals a match. Every team needs one.

As long as we dont get Gumbleton I'm quite happy.

Nicky dal would be good.

I just think that we can get quite good players with our picks from this year's draft

i have a question?

i have seen plenty of Viney in training and matches.

how good do you guys think he is going to be? Cotchin like?

or will Boak trump Viney?

who cares what school you guys went too or accusations about schools its ridiculous.

all i care about is who were are going to pickup

Chappy is way too old.

i would love Kelly as he is younger than Bartel

Stevens could be a great pickup especially because we could get him cheap.

Gumby=waste of time

Garlett=waste of time, doesnt perform unlesss 10 goals up

Gibbs= YES, would be a goddard type of player at melbourne, him and watts DELICIOUS

i do honestly believe Boak is worth pick 4. hes a gun.. just sometimes players dont work out, id just be worried he doesnt fit into melbourne

I am really sorry and ithink you all know this in your hearts, as much as id LOVE to see Travis Boak leading us to melbournes 13th premiership.. i do not believe he will be at Melbourne in 2013. Whoever can post whatever articles they want its really unlikely to ever happen. Boak has interest in Geelong and Port Adelaide are going to fight tooth and nail to keep him.

If we offer Boak a stack of money hell consider but im pretty hellbent on the fact he is not coming to the demons.