Wells 11

Ok....but you can't possibly be wrong outlining these. Take a risk, which scenario are you going with? I think Im with scenario 2.

My fear, and I want to be wrong about it, is that Goody has lost the players. When I see a series of dropped chest marks, the first two goals given up by 50 metre penalties, simple skill errors on repeat and a general lack of energy it points to something intangible . To be honest It jogged some dark memories of the Neeld era. You could just feel the team wasn’t switched on from early on in the 1st. Goody is our only living premiership coach, I mean him no disrespect, but something feels very wrong. Do you have an opinion?

I haven't read this whole thread so please update me if its been covered. But, if we were going to go into a rebuild through the draft in 25 then we have to know its supposed to be a weak draft. So I just can't see the value in it. We've got some great young kids...I say lets lets top up not sell the farm for this. Not this year and not next re Tasmania. Oliver and Trac may well improve as this year goes on. The game plan on the other hand...thats another thing.

wait… don’t sack goody!

is @Webber in the house? he’ll have something to add I hope!

100% after the siren… wtaf is going on. fritsch dropping a chest mark 20 out from goal. … missing 2 sodas. They generally look lost. Something is wrong with this team.

Effort and intensity is there. Ball movement, skills, kicking are just Truly horrible… how we’re just 17 down is a miracle. On the cards they open this up at some point and win by 60 plus.

Windsor, Kozi and Lindsey

subbed off with a knee. Don’t know beyond that.

This team seems like it has lost all confidence. Not sure how they can turn this around.

this is borderline embarrassing

Turner was everywhere. 5 goals up forward and marks everything when down back. Surely he gets back in.

MFCSS pessimism. Suns by 6 goals. Hope I’m wrong.

Sadly I think I agree...he cant catch a break can he.

the obvious lack of energy , not just in the last but all day might confirm this. Hopefully it’s that and nothing more culturally sinister.,

whoever he is he’s pathetic too…did you see how the ball slipped off their boots? he was probably moved over from the laundry department and clearly hasn’t got a clue!

he hasn’t really played yet… give it time.

add in May, Pickett and Windsor and things look a little different I think.

yeah I saw that too . Tough for Billing’s but his kicking for goal is just a liability.

opinion or inside info?

May won’t play this weekend. It’s in the injury report.

JVR was one of the big disappointments on the day for me. I understand wet conditions etc but he just didn’t look anywhere near it. Should he have been given some time in the ruck to at least get him into the game?

yep..it both sealed the game and appeared to be his / our redemption against his premature, first game, gang tackling, pies. BOG that day and the next year not playing for us and the next retired. AFL footy is tough sport.

no question… but the question coming back is what’s the limit of how far we go re trading players and salary?

In retrospect didn't the dees end up offering what would have been 4 x 1st rounders for him? ( given where we finished last year) . If so thats an offer they will never get again and are no doubt regretting not taking as much as I am glad it didnt happen. We dont need saviours....and we've been down that track too many times.