Jaded No More

I would like to see him played as a tagger. Harmes is a better user of the ball and better when resting forward and I believe he is past his tagging days save for a special occasion. We saw Viney in the early days thrive when given specific jobs on Ablett, Dangerfield and Selwood. He is a natural tackler and hunter of the ball, so tagging seems to be right for him. His ball use is simply trash when left to his own devices.

Correct me if I’m wrong, but aren’t the captains voted in by the players? Edit: I know years ago it was a vote by the players with final sign off by the coaches. Has this changed?

How many more injuries will we sustain in these last two weeks? Honestly this season can not end quickly enough.

Big difference going head to head and being made to change how you play to specifically nullify an opponent. Obviously Gawn and Grundy would go head to head. But the instructions should have been, made him chase you. Our mark him. Smash him in hit outs. Do your thing. Not, don’t worry about your game just ensure Grundy is nullified. It makes no sense.

Correct. If you’re picking players on their positions, Gawn is hands down the best RUCKMAN in the game. His ruck stats are simply superior. So if you’re picking a ruckman it has to be Gawn. If you’re just picking 22 midfielders than sure Grundy gets the nod.

The fact that Goodwin made Gawn, the best ruckman in the league, tag Grundy makes me feel sick. How can a coach be this dumb? Does Fyfe tag Martin? Wtf is this strategy? Let’s nullify our best player by making him nullify an equally good player. And let’s do it in the ruck. Words fail me.

Any chance these guys will go down to training and teach our players how to kick?

Honestly now May is out for the season with his third hamstring, you gotta question why we keep bringing in under done players or players with a history of injuries to play in a dead season. An early pre season start for May would have been far more beneficial than playing today. He came to us unfit so make him work to fix that. We know he can play, we don’t know if we can play more than 2 matches in a row without getting injured.

That’s really harsh. I know hating on Omac is flavour of the month but he honestly played well today. Was aggressive at the ball, and hit targets. Considering he’s never played forward or ruck, he did well. Needs a break. He’s hardly the core of our issues.

Things I hated: 1. The lack of defensive running 2. The match ups. Nobody on Sidebottom was brilliant. 3. May injured 4. Lever kicking the football 5. Anyone other than Salem and Lewis kicking the football 6. The two more games we have left to endure

Hard for anyone to commentate a Melbourne game and not be negative. We are woeful.

May hamstring. Lol. You have to question why they didn’t just let him have an early start to the pre season to get him cherry ripe instead of getting him in half fit every time.

He’s played his quarter. What did you expect? Another player who hasn’t improved and never will because he isn’t fit.

Honestly I don’t know how people can have blind faith in Goodwin and then watch this [censored] unfold every week. Injuries are one thing. Being a dumb coach with no understanding of your team or your opponent is another. This is as easy a win as any team will have this year.

Embarrassing stuff. Most embarrassing is the coaching and match ups.

Lever is having a stinker. Needs a pre season to get himself right.

In the backline for some unknown reason when he was doing well up forward. Meantime Hore is in the VFL.

Which idiot coach in the box will make a move to tag Sidebottom?! Do something you incompetent bunch of hacks.

Everyone at the contest. Nobody around the outside. Collingwood win a clearance. Goal.

Disgusting lack of pressure. I’m over watching us do the same [censored] every week.

Name one of his teammates who hasn’t done that this season.

I reckon JHK has done more than Gus, Jones and Oliver today to be honest. Melksham clearly not ready for AFL. Gawn looks like he’s done with this rabble of a team for the season and now poor Oscar has to have his confidence destroyed further by rucking against Grundy.

Yep chaos ball. Goodwin’s brilliant game plan which hasn’t worked for a year and relies on winning every clearance and skills we do not possess such as kicking, handballing and foot speed.

Hibbo the easiest turnover you’ll see. Honestly we are painful

[censored] me!!!!! Why these unskilled rubbish players why?! Kill me