demon3165

Don't think so..?

Viney with football nouse and skill unlike the rugby player/

Connecting with the forward line with the tall guys need some work if they can get that right they could be a real weapon, their running pattens are hit and miss.

He hurt his fingernail....should be right.

Do we have a midfield coach the one we have is useless absolutely got smashed in the midfield.

So does Viney but people just love the rugby player..

And who is our midfield coach? part problem with the centre clearances is Max no longer jumps for the ball Goldstein cleaned him up in that area last week last around the ground Max is great but this is one area he is struggling against good ruckman.

Ahhh so miss the sixties and seventies....

I could think of another team that people call them that..????

Spot on he just not a rugby player.

Daw soft as butter no intensity at all.

Teams like Richmond, Geelong etc we are going to win today Melbourne supporters think we will depending what team turns up today to play, hopefully we can just get used to winning and not drop games we should win.

Not on your pat malone there I cook dinner here.....

Ah the days when dinner was on the table at 6 how things have changed...

What a load of crap next one of these coaches will suggest that they should be allowed an opposition sub to be used for them if they have more than 2 injuries to even up the bench how about this coaches coach and the AFL screw up the game with rule changes.....

Spot on with the centre bounce analogy this has been happening for quite a while and against good teams it will be still a problem for the midfield group but his around the ground work is brilliant.

That's my opinion does not make you right back up that he is not then.

Yep side step run off and kick a goal he will be still trying to turn around so....

Look you have your opinion Viney has only one thing going for him his tackling other than that lacks football nous, not a great kicker of the ball I tell you what if you think he's an A grade footballer look up his stats since he has played for from 2013 till now and compare with any other top midfielder in the comp even Oliver has scored more Brownlow votes than him, look I hope he can change his game style but I doubt it.

No don't think he is slow he is slow.

Add Viney to those two.

Agree with Viney add Vanders to that list.

LOL viney and speed unless he has changed his game style the saints will expose him with his opponent running of him, if the game is locked down in the midfield then that is his style. The biggest problem is Gawn he no longer jumps for a tap just stands under the ball and trying to out muscle his opponent, midfield is getting beaten more often than not as the opposition are starting to pick him off.

Could not have said it better myself.....

How true I would also put in Jones in there.