jackaub

AHHHHHH the old lack of a preseason have all our players that excuse

Do not get ANY Carlton players never ever they are softer than our lot

Yeah great just watt we need !

Best avaiable means nothing if he cant play

Hey Sambo what about the point? You think Toumpas was an inspired selection Watch the game before you comment you obviously were either asleep or you didnt watch

Hey Mate doesnt seem to effect Jones does it you apologist along with half the idiots on this forum

Jumbo yoo are so right!

Hey Titan {people here have made excuses for players like Silvia the whole of their careers Dont you get it? This is where it starts !Silvia should have been exposed early in his career= Grimes also Davey Is a joke! Some here support them all in spite of their serial underperforming See the reality!!

Hey Ben You are part of the reason MFC is where its is now you keep making excuses for these players Doesnt happen at other clubs do you understand that

SO why select him if you know that

so where are all the Jimmy Toumpas supporters Sorry Apologists today Come on guys Lets see Needs a preseason injured young needs games UHMMMMMM maybe he s not goodf enough! Geesus pick players who are ready to playMeybe he needs 5 years like Jascie boy Wha a joke Blind fReddy could see Toumpas wasnt ready

That the Carp BB is talking about Titan

Exactly BB59 people on here just dont get it We do not have the time and the recruiting should reflect it.It just hasnt and even a simple choice like Wines over Toumpas shows that the club doesnt know what it is doing Martin over Trengove e list goes on and on and on!

Doesnt the mfc evaluate the mental side of a player when making a selection at the draft? It seems to me to be a continuing problem at the club and amongst our playersor is the the club enviorement that effects players mentally

So How long will it take? to have him impacting games

Gee and Melboune didnt need a ready made player This club needs to get serious We NEED ready made players now!

I just wish Melbourne had a forward who 1) didnt jump at he contest with all the others and 2) stayed on his feet goalside Given the size and structure of our forward line there is plent of spilled ball to pounce on BTW why do we lead and kick into the pockets You dont need a small forward if you are smart

I dont know who is better and who may become better! All I know that in the past on most occasions that MFC have Had to choose between two high picks They have always got it wrong because we have had very poor recruiting and analysis ( We may have even been influenced by general opinion) Let's hope not this time My only comment is that the club doesn't enjoy the luxury of time any more so ready made is good for the future in my humble opinion

Yes a bit like old Rexy you knew everything except where the ball was and who had it quite appalling

Runs a close second to B Taylor What a dribbler!

Agree completely! I have tried a number of times to enjoy facilities at the club Got lost every time i tried to visit! Was treated appallingly by lazy slow dim-witted staff who didnt give a damn The venue offered absolutley nothing to demon supporters Had to request several times to have television replay turned on Tried to get a group regularly to join me for dinner and a few beers watch the replay all aggreed atmosphere was bad Worst venue I have ever attended MFC either changes management or dumps the place It will nver make money being run as it is! The club must get this right