-
Posts
1,639 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Store
Posts posted by Tatu
-
-
Can we possibly trade miller to the gc this year???
Doubt it but worth the question.
herd somewhere that the hawks are intrested in miller, as a defender.
-
Now that Casey are assured of finishing 5th or 6th in the finals the question will be which Melbourne based plyers will be available and eligable to play for them come finals time to hopefully secure some silver wear? Off the top of my head the players I came up with that may be available and eligable are:
Buckley
Bartram
Miller???
Dunn
Cheney
Newton (if fit)
McNamara
Jetta???
Bail (if fit)
Spencer
Bennell???
Valenti
Whelan (if fit)
Jurrah
McKenzie
Not sure if I've missed anyone, and also not sure on whether Miller, Jetta or Bennell have played enough games to qualify, also will be waiting on fitness of Newton, Bail & Whelan.
Anyone know if I've missed anyone or if any of the above wont be able to make a finals appearance?
J watts would qualify maybe
-
is the saints late form a concern for them, they have a habbit of dropping good season.
could this late form drop effect there finals?
-
Brayshaw i think it was, was talking about how Butcher's suss kicking ability will seriously limit his overall output. They then went on about how you can only improve a players kicking roughly 10-15% (i think it was) once they reach 17 or 18. Changing someones kicking style is one of the hardest things to do in coaching of you believe those 4.
Garry went on about his son already having a bad kicking style and how he refuses to listen to his old man to correct it. Doesn't look so good for a father son pick up there.
Brayshaw would love it if butcher fell to north's pick.
-
Jurrah is going to be a brownlow winning midfielder, who rests forward and kick's 5 goals.
-
i like it. do it.
be happy with that.
1. scully
2. butcher.
13. stevens
18. panos.
be happier with this.
-
Again, Bailey obviously begs to differ.
I don't see how you can make such a call. Leadership aside, the club wouldn't pick McDonald if they didn't think he would be able to play to a required level or such that he was being given a "charity" spot in the side. Not a good message for the players and not a good situation to keep a player.
We are NOT any other club and quite frankly that question gets bandied around from time to time too often about players with little regard to context. We are MFC and we have our own priorities and goals and it would not be prudent by the club to not ensure we have the best possible group of young players as we go forward. Given the circumstances, the MFC brains trust beleives that he is good enough to play for our team and that is all that matters - but if you really want a team I'll say Port, I'll take McDonald over Josh Carr atm. McDonald is not going to be consistently cutting it up next year, you don't expect that from a 33 yr old but that isn't the point. He can play at a good level though as we have seen in the last month. We are talking one more year here not a 3 yr contract. He is on the veterans list ffs so the cost is minimal for such a potential gain with our list going forward. I admit that I am a touch surprised at how keen the club was to re-sign him but that's the point isn't it? - I'm on the outside and they are the inner sanctum and if they were that keen to sign him then he must be doing something right and play a very important role that many of us may not understand.
agree...
-
with out robbo there, Bruce and Mcdonald are the only players able to go on the veterans list.
it also give's the football department a year to work out MFC next captain.
-
Both are future stars of the AFL, but i'll wait till they play for the MFC.
-
Mark Couglin looks like he's on the outter at richmond.
noticed Chris Dawes was out this week, would we trade for him? what would he cost?
-
west coast want to trade first round pick.
-
Richo
Lloyd
Grant
Neitz
Hall
Lucas
Tredrea
O'Louglin
Robbo
Rocca
-
was resently told that MFC may have a few father-son prospects coming though, is this true?
should MFC change who they pick in the 09 draft, according to who they may get with father-son in a few years?
should MFC set up an introduction camp for father-son prospects?
-
hope wheels gets 150
-
i'd say west coast would already have someone in mind.
-
B: J Strauss M Warnock J Bennell
HB: J Grimes C Garland J frawley
C: C Morton T Scully A Davey
HF: C Silvia J Watts L Jurrah
F: B Green J Butcher A Wonaeamirri
R: J Meesen B Mclean J Viney
IN: S Matin J Rivers S Blease B moloney
E: N Jones S Buckley A Maric M Bate
-
saints
-
carlton may think of melb's PP as to much of a threat in the future(2012-2015).
they might drop this one.
-
davey would suit vice-captain more than captain.
moloney would be a great captain.
-
newton would be alright if he could kick.
we really need a full forward who can kick goals from anywhere within 60m.
Trengove/Butcher/Panos/Jetta dilema
in Melbourne Demons
Posted
there's no way of knowing who the best availble is, it could be scully, it could be butcher, it could be Trengove......etc
if they make it at all.
I'm happy for MFC to make the call, on who to take.
if picks 1 & 2 give's us anything, it's hope.