Adam The God

Do elaborate, please...

Michael Talia was pretty ordinary against us earlier in the year, but I'll back the club again on this.

Well, my friends are all drug addicts. But yes, it was hilarious yesterday. They were texting about Waite and Betts the night before. Great stuff. Ultimately, it's disappointing that we're having a conversation about Melksham, because it says a lot about the state of our list.

Not the Carlton supporters I know. They loved him, but admitted he might do better in a different environment.

Lol. When did people froth over Riley, Michie, Newton, Magner, Couch etc?

People are probably right when they say it depends what we'd give up for him. I still say it's pretty pointless and knowing Essendon they'd want a 2nd rounder, possibly even a first rounder. If we paid that we'd be idiotic.

Agreed. I'm certainly doubting his ability to contribute positively and consistently.

Exactly. I want us to get rid of Grimes too, so to be adding Melksham seems redundant.

I'm just not convinced he's much of an upgrade, if at all on blokes like Matt Jones and Bail. It'd be a step backwards in terms of where our list is. He can run, but he's a turn over merchant. Sound familiar?

I hope Goodwin's got it, but too early to tell. The players appear to really like him though.I posted my best 22 for next year on another thread the other day. It involves going after A graders in Prestia and Bennell and landing them both. Melksham wouldn't even make the emergencies in that scenario. Ultimately, I don't want us going after blokes with suspect disposal and decision-making. We've been there, done that.

They're past the point of no return a lot of these blokes. Much like a lot of our blokes who have moved to other environments (Blease, Sylvia, Moloney, Morton etc) and failed. The Milk Man has been Essendonised, so even if he was a reliable disposer of the football (clue, he's not), he's mentally scarred. Move on. We should be trying to improve our best 22, not going after depth. That's not how you build lists. We should be attempting to improve our 22. Some of the guys that we already have will become depth if we can improve our 22.

Lol. The Milk Man. Possibly the last player I'd want us to draft. With ASADA hanging over his head, talk about players being scarred.

History also suggests that changing clubs has no effect. Exhibit A, James Frawley. Are we seriously saying if Jack Grimes switched clubs, all of a sudden his horrid decision-making and disposal would improve? Come on. It's the same with The Milk Man.

I trust the FD, but if they go after this guy, a lot of that trust will be broken. I don't care how much intimate knowledge Goodwin has of him, I've seen enough of him to trust my own judgement and we don't need another Grimes, but what's potentially even worse is that he could he banned from playing. Dumb, dumb, dumb if true.

So... Hamish Harltett. I wouldn't say no, but surely we need a bit more leg speed. I guess it'd depend on what we'd give up for him. What do the rest of you think?

Don't really care how courageous someone is if they turn it over or put team mates under pressure every time they get it.

No chance.

He is the Essendon supporter whipping boy and for good reason. A turn over merchant in the Jack Grimes mould. Need I say more?

Nope. It was at the 'G and Travis Johnstone ran around by himself for 46 or 47 possessions.

Thought he was incredibly ordinary for the first half. Worked himself into the game after half time, but was so-so for mine. Calling him a champion of the game is beyond laughable.

And if they replied to them, it'd make them look pretty amateur, IMO.

Lol. Moloney was never an A grader. He was a downhill skiing B grader.

An embarrassment of riches up there. Glad at least, to see Treloar going home. The more their talent is dispersed across the league, the less threatening they become. The same with Gold Coast.

With McCarthy and Tomlinson ahead of him and injuries included, I wonder if we could get him cheaper?

I note Jon Patton's not getting a game. MFC supporter as a kid, was on the rise before his injury. Big lad. Does anyone think he'd be a good foil for Hogan?