What part of 'That is all they had to offer' don;t you understand.
They only picks they have right now are 11, 23, 49, and 81. How are they going to get 2 first rounders out of that lot.
And don't say the pick for Neale because that deal has not been done.
Let me spell it out for you.
Freo have no ammunition, that is why they traded pick 6 out; to get extra picks to meet their minimum trade obligations.
Unless they trade Neale they can and could not offer any more than they already have. For them to get Hogan they have to trade Neale.
They only have picks 11, 23, 30 ,49, and 81.
I think you are correct.
In 2018
1. Check the win/loss ratio with him in the side against without him.
2. His style of play, reaction time does not fit with our game plan,
Just thoughts.
"It was reported Carlton flew Shiel to Noosa for a meeting that featured Judd, as well as coach Brendon Bolton, list boss Stephen Silvagni, football manager Brad Lloyd and billionaire Bruce Mathieson. "
Why would billionaire Bruce Mathieson be there?
To hand out brown paper bags?
Smells like Carlton could be rorting the salary cap in some sneaky way.
I have emailed/twittered th club 4 to 5 times in the last 2 years and am still waiting for a response to my queries.
If they want to ignore me then I will ignore them. It's my money.