Alotta

Part of the criminal gang? No tanking on Gardner's watch. Unhelpful maybe but Chopper won't be a witness for the prosecution whatever his theories.

Just because they interview Chopper doesn't mean he committed the crime, has any first hand knowledge of the crime, was at the scene of the crime or even has any more knowledge about the crime than you, me or the lamp post. Whatever Chopper says does not make life any more difficult for the criminal.

Agree.

I actually agree with this. It would have been preferable that he not buy into this even if he was at pains to point out "as a supporter" not in any official capacity at the time in question or since. But this does not justify the revisionist history of his period as Chairman or the vilification of a man who made our club better than it was at his cost and without consideration of personal reward.

Chill pill, kiddies. Gardner left the Club waaaay better than he found it. Debt,world class facilities(AAMI), membership, governance, Casey, FD personnel and resources, MCC relationship, inclusivity of women etc. His greatest failing was his propensity to take on Vlad and the Kremlin which hurt us (ironic given that many in his lynch mob also demand we take on city hall now). The Stynes/McLardy board has made further progress as Gardner alluded to and praised in the SEN interview that few seem to have actually heard. But the great achievement on his watch was unity and credible football/win- loss/finals appearances. The great fraud of the current administration is it's claim to have unified (they have not) a disunited (it was not) Club. The bitter divisions of 2011 are unprecedented since 1965. The raw wounds of this disunity are at the heart of the despondency we all feel and our dysfunctionality as a footy club. Who wouldn't exchange the Gardner 2004-June 2008 40% plus winning record with the 20% winning performance of the last 4 years of weekend misery for which Stynes/McLardy/Schwab/Connolly are responsible? Thanks Paul.

Has anyone here actually listened to the Gardner interview readily accessible on the SEN website and app? Too much red cordial consumed from you thunderingly indignant numpties. He doesn't mention Craig Cameron once. He says not once but twice that his tanking observations were based on his presence as a spectator ie after he stepped down as Chairman. He praises McLardy. I defy anyone who actually listens to the interview to be offended by it. Disagree at some things maybe. Offended - petal!

Herb Matthews x 3