beelzebub

Absolutely agree. Currently we are dead in the water. Might find my skis...

And we knew all of this before the first bounce.... totally validated by the last. Sadly, imho, it won't matter who we play (our list ) as long as your opening comment resonates Souffles are not made with soup recipes

Mathews ...stoppages McPherson... Football operations. A lot of people are Not Roos' people Hird should never be allowed near any sport EVER again. Lyon has done enough for us...he can stop.

No not directly. It was Pert who signed ( re-signed ) Goodwin with unnecessary haste.

Or might just be underdone and has been brought in to provide some skill....or he's not. So hard to tell at Melbourne !!!

Our style...for want of a better word ...of football only worked (sic) whilst opposition allowed it. Once teams twigged...they deny us our game and play theirs. We are so dumb we just keep going our way...but are no longer relevant as better ( probably at a count of 17 now ) teams have worked us out Sadly the FD hasn't worked out that we've been worked out.

Anyone ????

The Melbourne brand of footy ... As designed by the FD I see similarity... except....a Camel is actually useful. Imho...a lot of our situation is by decree. We've set out to play a particular style. It invariably ignores/over-rides/ dispenses-with any inherent footy nous of our players and replaced it with a draconian nonsense that is easily picked apart. Some players are indeed woeful, but many are simply incapable of playing a game style which itself is incapable of sustainability. We play rubbish.....by design.

Changes ?? Out Melbourne....in Collingwood...they know how to play the game. We sure as hell don't. I need to shower now...

Changes for next week ? Too vast a job...with far too little to choose from.

We got the wrong one.... should have gone for Charlie. At least it would have been entertaining.

More than one Elephant

A lot of our game is just too amateurish. I think from recollection you also expected a poor result. It's rather numbing.

No. In fact common sense my have dictated such. Wait a minute..common sense, silly me. Mr G wasn't going anywhere as such and a clever operator would have kept his powder dry. No overly impressed with this Pert. Seems to eager to rush things...good recipe for f#@&ing things up often. Yes Jaded, pretty ordinary ..and seemingly by design

I'm really not sure why anyone expected much different. We play dumb football...with a few too many dumb footballers, with a few too many who ought not be on the field , because they're not fit or ready or past it. Our brand .....it's rubbish... laughable. 2018 was the aberration. Over to you Simon.....you better wake up to yourselves quickly. Finals ? Forget those for the moment. Let's get back to basics. Back to being the laughing stock. All the foundations that Roos and Jackson put into place.........???? Sydney must be salivating. Yes, we certainly prepared well for this year. I take absolutely no joy from this debacle. How many more years of this [censored] I wonder. Can't wait for all the blah blah blah from Goschs way. Let's see what kind of FD we really have. Forget 2018 This is is 2019, this is the now, this is the reality....and it's not pretty. Another long week ahead...oh... actually just 6 days....marvee That other bloke was almost on the mark... Melbourne... we're twaddle !!

so @La Dee-vina Comedia What did Murdoch press run in Sydney and Brisbane ?

Yep !!!! Trac is something of an opportunist player. There's an art to being a lead up forward. He doesn't strike me as it.

Fair point

On a serious note. If all we do tonight is gang up on the ball and bomb...well. Season over. It's touted this isn't our desired method. But I just don't see football as THAT complicated that you CAN'T adapt to a situation by considering options. Surely these are part of the DNA of any decent player. Otherwise they're just robots...and an oval ball doesn't lend itself to predictable outcomes. You need a choice of tools in your kitbag... constantly. If we aren't really playing our proper game....well doesn't say much for the coaching. Yes Simon...no excuses ( never were at your level and remuneration surely ) Just fix it. If you can. If not.......

@La Dee-vina ComediaComedia you do know the HUN is an Essendon mouthpiece ? Bloke in charge...a rabid Bomber. Probably why Rubbishon keeps his job

Sorry Chazz... I'm going to have to agree with you

You have to question the logical powers of anyone suggesting judgement based on performance when we're rubbish.No ?

Gee...let's look at this. Melbourne ...almost a flavour of a months some little while ago.and now as putrid as mouldy apple .... Essendon ... continually 'imaged' as a victim...a club trying to get back to footy...all nicely nicely. Even the illusion that Hird is kinda back. ( Nauseating ) But Essendon isn't off to its Rosey start. It's playing Melbourne....and lo and behold...this BS comes out from that blubbering tool and his Essendon mad boss !! Go on tell me that's all completely accidental !! ?

There are those who still have sharp knives for us. There is still corruption at many levels of this sport. There is still a power collusion among some. We don't fit in.