Wodja

What’s Collingwood ever done for Melbourne? Answer - In the past few years they have caused us (me) abject misery. I honestly hope we can return the favour a little in the last game of the home & away season (our mini grand final in August)🤞

Yeah, I know it’s not going to happen because said he wasn’t interested and I guess they are looking for someone new ( which I can totally understand) but if he was asked and said yes I wouldn’t be disappointed. I would much prefer him to Buckley.

First few comments are very much self vested Pretty much from the day Buckley absconded to the Ferals from Brisbane I very much got on and stayed on the ‘I love to hate Buckley’ bandwagon for so many reasons. It was a long and good ride. So just on that level it would trouble me if he ended up our coach. The only person I would even more dislike having as our coach is Hird. I actually despise him for what he did at Essendon. Unforgivable, particularly more so because he is still in denial that he did no wrong. Ironically I think he would be a far better coach than Buckley. I would be most happy if we got fresh blood in as our new coach. As mentioned by others, first time new coaches seem to do better than recycled coaches.

1st Quarter- Game on!!

Purely from a curiosity perspective, considering what just happened a few days ago and your close relationship with some of the players, what sort of Melbourne do you think will front up this afternoon? I flip and flop, I can see a real statement game or I can see them going through the motions. In other words, I have no idea😐 If I had to guess, sadly it will be the later, hope I’m proven wrong

In my mind the difference is simply respect….to the bloke that got us our first flag in 57 years.

Something just doesn’t feel right about today. Sure there are arguments for and against Goody staying, but I’m still grieving a bit. Just like I suspect quite a few players are. Come what may, he was our premiership coach and he always had our players best interests….and was and still is a bloody good bloke. Some people were critical of Langdon’s presser the other day for essentially saying as it is rather than spin. I certainly wasn’t. Call it as it is. On the flip side not long after, there was Gawny doing the spin as expected saying something to the effect that he was amazed how quickly he and the side has moved on. It was very easy to see right through this. He was just doing his job. In my opinion he clearly was not a happy man. Go Dees for today and the following two weeks. Not sure what team turns up though. Footy supposedly is always bigger than any individual. But also go Goody (yeah I know his financially secure and all that) I still wish him all the best. No matter which way you slice it or dice it, the club hierarchy at the end of the day [censored] on him. And he felt it. Go Dees.

All through my working life I was always amazed at the number of extroverts that knew how to say all the right things at the right time and they inevitably got the ‘job’. When they came on board and people scratched a little deeper, in a lot of instances they were found out to be as deep as a puddle in a desert. Actions speak louder than words. Buckley appears to be a front runner. If he gets the job I just hope that he is not one of those kind of extroverts. Time will tell.

Pretty much agree with all of the above comments. The AFL is an absolute basket case. It is a self vested hypocritical commercial entertainment industry. I also totally agree that in this day and age that we must try and look after the physical welfare of our players. You can manage risks by trying to reduce them but practically speaking you can’t totally eliminate them. Football is a contact sport and there are risks and accidents will occasionally happen. I can only keep saying that in my opinion both May and Newcombe’s unfortunate collisions should not have been cited nor should they have been suspended. Neither player showed malice or intentionally tried to hurt the other player. All four players (in both incidents) were just trying to win the football. Simple as that.

Absolute [censored] isn’t it

I understand the logic of what you are saying but of course it’s not going to happen. I am just bemused by the irony of how two accidental collision are seen so differently. Even from a Channel 7 commentary perspective. From what I recall from the other week we were shown multiple slow motion replays of the May incident, but last night it was a different story. The AFL and the majority of its commercial partners stink. The only thing that ‘pleased’ me about the May incident was how many people in the football community not aligned to the MFC (putting aside and ignoring the click bait Nazis) said that he should not be suspended. For what it’s worth my opinion is that Jai Newcombe should not be cited or suspended, nor should have May.

Interesting how they don’t do a slow mo replay like they did for May. But we all know this won’t go anywhere I also reckon nor should it….neither should have May’s collision

The answer to your question. Absolutely nothing. To be honest neither player should be reported or suspended……nor should have May.

The Big Crunch. Thinking of the May suspension, I would like to think that someone will be suspended…. so there is some consistency