Roost it far
Annual Member
-
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Currently
Viewing Topic: Time to start a rebuild?
Everything posted by Roost it far
-
2023 Positives
Positive that we got a higher draft pick than we anticipated
- POSTGAME: SF vs Carlton
-
The 2023 Draft and Trade Targets Thread
Must recruit a key defender
-
The 2023 Draft and Trade Targets Thread
Neither Turner or Adams are big enough to cover May, Tomlinson is.
- Welcome to Demonland: Shane McAdam
-
2023 Positives
Had to make body contact, absolutely had to. A free to Docherty wouldn't of mattered.
-
The 2023 Draft and Trade Targets Thread
Key needs May replacement, this is an absolute key. I'm worried about losing Tomlinson. Brayshaw replacement if it's a second rounder. Outside/Inside class in the vein of Horne-Francis x 2. New winger/s (maybe Howes and/or Woewodin) I'd be transitioning our game away from relying on a dominant ruckman. We just need a beast who competes and can take the odd mark. Funnily enough I think a forward half of Petty, JVR, Fritsch, McAdam, Pickett and Petracca is fantastic. I really hope we're training this all preseason.
-
The 2023 Draft and Trade Targets Thread
Out of interest what's the long answer?
-
Cool light of day
We need the young one
-
Cool light of day
Missed again
-
Cool light of day
Keep swinging champ, you might land one eventually
-
Cool light of day
It’s insurance, ideally you never use it but you pay it every year.
-
Cool light of day
it’s not the coach
-
Cool light of day
I’be been thinking who we can shop around for draft picks and pkayers The list in my mind is Salem, Langdon, Grundy and Sparrow. I love Tom but if we could get a really clean user for him, with some outside pace I’d be interested.
-
Is it the players or dysfunction at the management level?
Because we have forwards with little or no forward craft, mids who can’t kick and a use a plan to suit/minimise those weaknesses
-
What's needed in 2024
I’d be stoked if the club had the chutzpah to trade out Salem and Langdon, just can’t see it.
-
Cool light of day
I just watched players torch each other, give away undisciplined 50’s, slip over and miss goals I’d kick, hell, our skipper gets blamed for touching a goal line kick from Oliver while Smith and Fritsch gaze at their opponents competing. If that’s the best they’ve got then my question has been answered. These losses are squarely on the players.
-
Cool light of day
Last night felt inevitable, I’ve never seen us be so undisciplined, make so many crazy errors, ignore team mates in better positions and generally gift a lesser team a ridiculous win. I really hope Carlton win or go close against Brisbane as maybe that might rub in what we just blew. We need some fresh eyes in the coaching box…I’d be offering Justin Leppitsch whatever it takes to come on board. We need a replacement brewing for May, another forward and some elite ball users. I really hope Woewodin and Howe can replace one or both of our wingers. Langdon has fallen off a cliff and Hunter, while serviceable needs upgrading. If TMac and Brown remain on the list I’ll cry and we need to find Max some help. I still think we have an excellent list and I’m bullish for the next few years but jeez the last 2 weeks hurt. Onwards and upwards. Go Dee’s…..and remember gifting finals to your enemies is supposed to hurt. I guess my one worry in this homogeneous world where everything is seen as a transaction is do the players really really really want it. Would they walk over coals for each other and success. Or is making pasta on your socials and shaving your balls enough. That’s the question that concerns me with this team.
- GAMEDAY: SF vs Carlton
-
Concussion and where to next?
You’ve taken that out of context to prove your point. Good for you.
-
Concussion and where to next?
This conversation has zero to do with the Brayshaw incident
- GAMEDAY: SF vs Carlton
- GAMEDAY: SF vs Carlton
- GAMEDAY: SF vs Carlton
-
Concussion and where to next?
Very clever Sue! Whilst the risk of concussion from a high mark is lower than the other risks the risk is still there. Are we happy with that risk and the injuries that could result from it?