Graeme Yeats' Mullet

Yep as a neutral spectator it was a great game to watch and the only downside was horrible umpiring late in game

Agree Consistency is far more important than where you set the threshold for the decision to be paid Problem is, when you set the threshold really low the individual interpretation of dissent (which has element of subjectivity/feelings) will vary a lot - leading to worse inconsistency

Didnt AFL say decisions paid were correct, and there had been some "slippage" being decisions not paid (that should have been) How can Scott then say it can be up to umpires interpretation? It can't be both wrong (missed decisions) amd up to umpires to decide... Inconsistency is what infuriates people... this is designed for inconsistency, irrespective of whether you like the underlying rule or not.

The key issue is why are 90% (guesstimate, but would appear to be some large majority) of what AFL insists is breach of umpire dissent rules not being penalised just 5 rounds into season? "Slippage" (reported by Jon Ralph) can't account for that big an error, it must be that the rule simply doesn't make sense to the umpires, (who are supposedly receiving the dissent)

Hilarious 😂

Joh Ralph reported on OTC that the AFL have endorsed the decisions paid as correct and the (dozens of...) ones not paid have been errors by umpires and explained as "slippage" It's embarrassing for the AFL to be backing in a rule where only a few examples are being "correctly" umpired and the vast majority being ignored (and accepted as common sense by the whole football community)

Sums it up I think Hunt been a lot better last 2-3 weeks

Still a bit of work to do on 2022 expiries It's been a quiet few weeks since Sparrow news...

Awful umpiring in Ess Freo game At least they're consistently awful 😖

Win-Win Carlton demoralised in 2nd Half Port 0-5

Self destruction

Ugly for Port

Game times Ticketing being fixed seats everywhere and tickets opening in multi-round lots 4-6 weeks in advance - my mates are useless and struggle to commit 5 days innadvance let alone being able to lock away seats many weeks in advance

May played after illness yesterday... what a gun to produce that dominance

Lever spent last 9 mins on bench at emd and was hobbling a bit on that ankle, reckon he's a danger... Tomo is good cover with Smith in line also

No, but some people can make right [censored] of themselves, and Leon didn't

Watching the pressers How good is Leon Cameron...! Night/Day compared to Beveridge

Hunt was a lot better today, Sparrow, ANB, Spargo, Jordan, Harmes all good Great standard for the next level of players

Bedford a bit of a passenger... 🤷‍♂️

Max was immense tonight Took 3 or 4 contested marks at important time in middle of 2nd Qrt, and enabled mids to get right on top

Sitting top of ladder 4-0 and 141% And to have a big % boosting win.... how far we have come ♥️💙

Nice slice there

Has had a good game

A - Ma - Zing

Weid clunk and goal I am Nourished