Wiseblood

Thank God for that. He'd be no good to us sitting down.

Ha ha, forgot to add the 'example' bit at the top. Could you imagine the melt down if I started one? Wouldn't go down well.

Thought I'd make a new thread in case Clarry goes home. Here's how we could start it: So it seems, going by the 'Trade Hogan' thread, that it's okay for us to discuss hypothetical trades on players in case they want out of the club. You just never know when that may happen. We don't know what's going on inside their head, we don't know if they want a sea change and we can't believe a thing they say or that the club says. I mean, of course they'll be positive about the players, so don't listen to them at all. They don't know what they're talking about. Oliver may request a trade to Hawthorn, or Richmond, or Collingwood. Does anyone know who he supported as a kid? He may go there as well. I mean, this is based on nothing guys, but he may go one day. So it's good to have trade ideas and hypotheticals here that the club won't listen to just in case. So what do we want? 9 first rounders? I'd love to know so I can be at ease with his decision if he ever makes it. And don't tell me off, I'm allowed to discuss hyotheticals about required players who have given no indication of wanting out. It's might right. Cheers. Edit - forgot to add that this is just an example of what we should be doing for all players going by the logic of some in this thread. Bloke had given no indication of going home, yet we should be discussing hypotheticals. Madness.

Only if he absolutely wanted to go home and, even then, I'd take Cerra instead of Brayshaw if we could. Picks do nothing for me at the moment as we're a finals side so, unless the club had further deals in place, I wouldn't be too keen on it. Outside of that the club, Hogan himself etc have said he is super happy at the club and he doesn't want to go home. Go right ahead, OD. I don't know why you would waste your time on it, but hey, if it makes people happy, then discuss 'em until your hearts content.

I think the problem some have with this idea of trading Hogan is that they don't have a solution in place. So Freo just offer us two picks and Cerra? Does the club even want that deal? And if we get that deal, do we even want high picks at this stage or do they want to trade them on? Who is the player available that a club wants to give up so easily for those picks? There is no solution, it's pure hypothetical that is based on nothing. In fact, the thread was started by a shallow poster having a whinge. It wasn't even based on the go home factor which is what others are now trying to hang their hat on.

This is off topic, but we actually don't have many players from interstate anymore. Billy Stretch and Dean Kent are two that come to mind outside of Hogan, but the rest of our gun players are all Victorian. Smart recruiting I reckon. Anyway, I don't want this to devolve into anything more than it is. You guys want to talk about the hypothetical of Hogan going home, even though all indications point to the contrary, then go right ahead. You can also knock yourself out on that one as well. I'll stick by my opinion that it's a pointless conversation when there is zero indication that he wants to go back to WA and in doing so it's slightly disrespectful to the bloke and his value to our footy club. Cheers.

Can I start one on Oliver, then? You know, in case he one day requests a trade? Or do we start one on every interstate player on our list? I'm just going by your logic above, Moonie.

I posted that same thing yesterday, Moonie. I made it very clear that if he indicated that he wanted to go home then I'd expect the club to come up with a suitable trade to get it done. I'd be disappointed in him leaving, but at the same time we would at least get something in return. My point is that, outside of that, we shouldn't be considering trading him. We don't need to trade him - our list is strong, we have good coverage across the ground and we have a young list that is maturing together. Why we would trade him outside of a need to go home is what I don't understand. We don't need to do it.

I could reply with the same gif re: those who would consider trading him.

Don't forget your question marks. And I see you don't have a replacement for him. Cheers.

Is he? Who can replace him with? Where do we get the 47 goals from? I look forward to this answer.

You just answered your own question.

Apparently it isn't as important as squeezing in a bloke who has kicked 2 goals in 2 games. (And, for the record, I've loved Weid's output in the last two games.)

Me either. I would have liked him at the club, but if someone like North are offering godfather type money, then we need to step away and either look elsewhere or continue to back in others to improve.

Nothing emotional in it my friend. Just the facts.

If the thread was entitled 'Hogan's best position going forward' then I'd agree. But when the coach shoots down any chance of him being traded then what's the point of discussing it? Should we start a thread on every player and get some discussion going on how we might trade them as well? He was never going to be traded and, unless he wants out, the club will never consider it.

I wouldn't call them emotional outragists, Moonie. I'd just call them posters who see what Jesse brings to the team and how good the 1-2 punch of T Mac and Hogan could be for years and years to come. I'll add that, if he gave the club some indication that he wants to go back home, then I'd expect the club to follow up on a suitable trade to get that done. But if he doesn't then I'd suggest the club would not be looking at doing anything with him other than getting him fit and ready to fire in 2019.

He is our leading goal kicker and we were still the highest scoring side in the comp with him in it. Anyway, I don't know why we're worried about where Hogan plays right now. We should be focused on finals and enjoying that.

Those asking to trade Jesse better not be the ones in the next few years who get stuck in to a player for lack of loyalty if they don't sign a contract. We can't be so blase in just wanting to ship a player off and then cry foul when another doesn't want to sign. It works both ways.

Stuie is an admin of one of these Facebook groups. That should answer any question somebody might have about the level of intelligence going around on Facebook.

Yeah, you're a [censored] Wiseblood.

I always thought 'Petraccattack" was the infamous Yze_Magic, but I could be wrong.

His first half gave us a real glimpse of the player he could be - good hands, very mobile and, while his kicking for goal needs work, we can see that he hit the scoreboard as well. He could be a real handy addition for us with Hogan going down.

Imagine coming back to Victoria... to play for Norf. I guess they had to get someone on the hook with all that money. They've missed on everyone else.

Got get 'em, Sam! I'd love nothing more than to see him kick a few and cement a spot in the side for the rest of the season, however long that may be, with Hogan out. It's time to get behind him and back him in for a good game!