DubDee

I think the Hawks may be losing the plot. Vickery might have been carried by them last year but not from next year onwards. A poor player

I wouldn't mind a quiet trade period or two. Key for us is to keep our top 10 players under 22 yo. For the first time in a looooong time we have great young talent. When oliver tracca brayshaw etc have 50 games under their belt, bring in a senior gun.

See him as a better version of Sylvia. Constantly teases and looks like he should be a gun but does not deliver consistently. He was putrid in some games this year. He looks better in a top team but would not help us much at the moment imo.

tough call, but I would have picked Heppell in the draft instead

Don't get people thinking Pendles was stiff. he was below his usual best this year and carried an injury you dont get in on reputation alone.

People talk about player loyalty, where has club loyalty to the player gone too? he showed loyalty to stay last year and signed a 5 year deal and next year they tell him he might be traded? I have liked him, but he has been poor this year - especially when Port needed senior players to stand up. If we recruit senior players I would prefer mentally tough, strong leaders are recruited. otherwise keep working on our youth. port would not accept anything but a first rounder.

Toby Greene AA? serious WTF. at least voldemort missed out

Brisbane will 100% get a priority pick. i dont agree with it but it will happen. just keep tabs on him and we can steal him in 2 years.

surely GC would have offered him $750G/5 yrs. they would have been desperate for their VC to stay when everyone else is leaving... baffling why he would chose Tiges. apparently they have courted him for years maybe he agreed to join them last year, without their actual signature and didnt want to back out

Good get by the Tiges. No matter what stage of rebuild a 23 yo mid gun is always needed. if he passes the medical I would have loved him at the dees. Not much talent out there to trade in.

i dont see Freo improving. very old list, expecting a massive cull with not much youth coming through could be pick 2 next year!

Every now and then a piece of news comes out that is bad for GWS and the Pies and I like to just sit back and smile

well we played a lot better against good teams this year than poor teams so I'm hoping for a terrible draw full of top 8 teams.

you are forgetting afl is all about money. NAB want their name flashed around each week I would just have an award for the best first year player and an award for the next under 21 player. give them out a the brownlow of something

34 next year, can only play inside mid so it'd be a no from me. I'd prefer seeing brayshaw, Oliver, tracca etc get more time on the ball. Great player though and would happily have him as coach

Regarding 2016 overall, it was the most enjoyable year since 2006 - easily. i went to the footy each week and thought we could actually win. The win against the Hawks was just incredible. We scored freely, playing exciting footy, unearthed some gems. Only problem is we keep getting younger! cant wait to see the impact Brayshaw, Petracca and Oliver can make to our team next year (in particular). they will transform our midfield. Get stuck into preseason boys!

Regarding the lack of leadership issue, it is obvious we lack senior leaders. The only way to address it is to build leadership from within, we have a great crop of under 23's and we need to empower and develop them. Starting with Viney and T Mac and then onto Brayshaw, Oliver, Hogan in the years to come. Like Hawks did with their young crop. Recruiting leaders doesnt work that well IMO (although Crossy was awesome), we need to step up.

To me he looks mentally drained rather than physically. When did Vince get run down from behind last year? happened a lot this year. his concentration and focus have been poor He clearly has had issues with consistency at the crows (good year/poor year) so I think he should get an extended break from the club. does he need a 5 month preseason? a few extra weeks to freshen up and get the anger back and hunger score goals and get us to finals

Sack Goody! He hasn't done anything since he took over

Viney Gawn Jones T Mac Tyson next in line, Jetta, Watts although Viney slowed up at the end of the year, he still easily leads contested possessions and tackles and just leads the clearances. He led beautifully all year and pips Gawny just IMO

Delighted for Beaker. Fair to say he deserves a win after 2 wins in 7 years!! how he has kept fronting up for training is beyond me. I reckon he'll get a game in finals, the other young ruck will get dropped for mcevoy

How good is Roosey? gonna miss him

We already have Petracca, hogan and Viney.

I don't think you can have too many quality midfielders. Sydney haven't struggled with their 'one paced midfield with poor kicking skills' and they are again, rightly, flag favourites especially in a few years without vince and jones

Put a fork in him - he is done. Port would keep him if he was right