Demonland

He is right to have his opinion and I think many posters have reasonably shown that opinion to be misguided.

Spot on. This is simply a case of bad timing. I think all can agree that Yze would be the perfect replacement for Goody but due to the current circumstances of which ironically Yze is a big part of creating he will most likely get a gig elsewhere before the opportunity arises at the Dees. That is our loss but not something that is viable at this time.

Are you suggesting Yze will “walk” because he is disgruntled or “walk” for the opportunity to further his career?

Exactly. Which makes the possibility of him leaving for a senior role more likely. It has zero to do with being under-appreciated as the OP suggested.

If we “lose” Yze it will have absolutely nothing to do with being under-appreciated and everything to do with him having learned at the feet of two Premiership coaches, being one of the best assistants going around and deserving the shot at a senior coaching gig. It is very probable that Goody will get a contract extension and deservedly so after winning a Premiership. Therefore it is more likely that Yze will at some point Interview for a vacant senior coaching role and possibly get the gig. We all would love for a beloved ex-player to return to the club and coach us however the timing is not right and who are we to begrudge him from seeking to further his career if the opportunity arises. Yze came back at the start of 2021. The only way he’d be coaching us now or in the short term would be for Goody and the team to have spectacularly failed. Would you have preferred that outcome?

It was after this goal.

Please keep this thread free of arguments about coaches and assistants. Start another thread if you like but keep this one about the Covid situation at the Dees.

Imagine being Bayley Fritsch.

All teams are going to be hit with COVID at one time or another especially as we head into Winter. If we only have 3 out (there's still a few more days for others to turn) then we will have got off pretty lightly.

Imagine our defence with Rodman in the team.

clarification on the AFL’s isolation rules.

Everyone better get into the Brace position according to Channel 7.

Dees just posted some training photos from today. Can rule out the following players from the list of players with COVID or in isolation. * Baker * Fritsch * Hunt * May * Dunstan * Harmes * Bowey

If tested positive today they could have been contagious yesterday.

If that is the case and Luke and Toby have COVID then that means that Oliver will almost certainly be out this week too.

Thanks for the kind words about the podcast guys. Please leave 5 stars and Feedback on your preferred podcast service. It will help us a lot. Cheers.

Q: How do the Hawks come back after being 32-0 early, leading at every interval and then conceding nine goals in the last quarter to lose to the Swans by 41 points in the comfort and safety of their second home down in Launceston? A: If they’re playing the Demons at the G off a five-day break, there are no comebacks. They simply won’t come back! That’s the short form preview of the Melbourne v Hawthorn match up at the Home of Football this weekend. That is not to dismiss the young Hawks’ prospects but the way each team’s ANZAC Round games unfolded does not bode well for them. The Demons’ general play against the Tigers matched their dominant form from their previous game against the Giants in most aspects. The glaring distinction was in their shooting accuracy for goal which plunged from 76% to 29% in the course of a week. Part of the explanation for that was in the defensive set up they faced from Richmond but you can be sure that Simon Goodwin and his coaching team (to be led this week by Adem Yze sitting in the chair - and who better than an ex-Hawk to fill in for Goody while he rehabs?) will have been working on the necessary adjustments to counter such tactics should anyone try to use them again. Similarly, Melbourne should be ready for a three-peat of Hawthorn’s frenetically rapid start to games which saw them score three goals in six minutes before Geelong got a touch of the footy on Easter Sunday, then the first five against the Swans on ANZAC Day. I have a gut feeling that these opening bursts from the Hawks are restricted to public holidays and to when they play teams other than Melbourne. They can try to take the game on but they won’t get away with it this week and it wouldn’t help them either way because the effort required would see the life sucked out of them much earlier than usual. More bad news for Hawthorn is the fact that Jake Lever and Jack Viney have been declared available for the game after sitting out last week due to health and safety protocols, meaning that two of the club’s strongest weapons one defensive and the other attacking, will come into the side well rested and up for the fight. Handy replacements for Luke Jackson, Harry Petty, Kysaiah Pickett and Tom Sparrow who miss this week after testing positive for Covid19. And Jake Melksham should be highly motivated now that he’s been called in to replace Nibbler. The other factor that needs to be remembered is that while the statistics of last week’s Melbourne game were well below par because of the poor shooting for goal, the optics remained a high point in terms of the work rate, the system and the endeavour. All of these things will operate on Saturday evening to ensure that, for the Hawks, there will be no repeat of their late 2021 heroics and no comebacks. Melbourne to win by 23 points. THE GAME Melbourne v Hawthorn at the MCG Saturday 30 April, 2022 at 4.35pm HEAD TO HEAD Overall Melbourne 79 wins Hawthorn 87 wins 1 draw At the MCG Melbourne 39 wins Hawthorn 46 wins 1 draw Last 5 meetings Melbourne 4 wins Hawthorn 0 wins 1 draw The Coaches Yze 0 wins Mitchell 0 wins MEDIA TV - live and on demand on Kayo and live on Foxtel. Check your local guides. Radio - check your local guides. THE LAST TIME THEY MET Melbourne 11.13.79 drew with Hawthorn 12.7.79 in Round 18, 2021 at The MCG Early in the game it looked as though the Demons were going to blow their lowly opponent right out of the park but the plucky Hawks fought back, persisted and caused a major upset even if they didn’t come out of the contest with all four points. Melbourne’s midfielders in Oliver, Petracca and Viney all managed 30+ possessions but they were trumped by Tom Mitchell who almost got his team over the line. THE TEAMS MELBOURNE B: T.Rivers 24 S.May 1 J.Smith 44 HB: J.Jordon 23 J.Lever 8 J.Bowey 17 C: A.Brayshaw 10 C.Petracca 5 E.Langdon 15 HF: T.McDonald 25 S.Weideman 26 B.Fritsch 31 F: T.Bedford 12 B.Brown 50 J.Harmes 4 Foll: M.Gawn 11 C.Oliver 13 J.Viney 7 I/C: L.Dunstan 27 J.Hunt 29 J.Melksham 18 C.Spargo 9 Sub: K.Chandler 37 Emerg: O.Baker 33 M.Brown 38 A.Tomlinson 20 In: K.Chandler J.Lever T.McDonald J.Melksham J.Viney Out: L.Jackson (H & S Protocols) A.Neal-Bullen (H & S Protocols) H.Petty (H & S Protocols) K.Pickett (H & S Protocols) T.Sparrow (H & S Protocols) HAWTHORN B: J.Scrimshaw 14 S.Frost 8 B.Hardwick 15 HB: F.Maginness 32 J.Sicily 6 W.Day 12 C: J.O'Meara 10 T.Mitchell 3 L.Shiels 26 HF: C.Nash 11 L.Breust 22 C.Macdonald 31 F: D.Moore 13 J.Gunston 19 J.Impey 4 Foll: M.Lynch 18 J.Newcombe 44 J.Worpel 5 I/C: L.Bramble 16 J.Callow 45 C.Wingard 20 J.Koschitzke 23 Sub: D.Howe 17 Emerg: D.Grainger-Barras 24 K.Hartigan 28 N.Long 27 In: L.Bramble J.Callow D.Howe Out: D.Grainger-Barras (managed) H.Morrison (injured) J.Ward (managed) Injury List: Round 7 Michael Hibberd - Calf | Available Jake Lever - H & S Protocols | Available Jack Viney - H & S Protocols | Available Simon Goodwin - H & S Protocols | 1 week Luke Jackson - H & S Protocols | 1 week Alex Neal-Bullen - H & S Protocols | 1 week Kysaiah Pickett - H & S Protocols | 1 week Tom Sparrow - H & S Protocols | 1 week Daniel Turner - Foot | 2 weeks Christian Salem - Knee | 3-4 weeks Blake Howes - Foot | TBC

When we spoke to him on the podcast he indicated that his preference is from the coaches box.

Get well soon Premiership Coach Simon Goodwin.

Big blow for the Blues too.