Would be a great pickup. Robbo and Neitz haven't got that much more life left in them. Even with them still around I think he'd fit well. And if Melbourne get Sheedy, he is the master of disipline with recycled players.

No thanks

Why / why not? That's a pretty useless reply.

Signature is a bit out too.. Ratten has signed

And if Melbourne get Sheedy, he is the master of disipline with recycled players.

He sure did wonders with Zantuck, Murphy and Cupido.

I highly doubt fev will leave now rats is in charge, but i would look at him if it came up due to this year been a average draft in terms of depth (supposedly) so trading picks would not worry me as much.

I highly doubt fev will leave now rats is in charge, but i would look at him if it came up due to this year been a average draft in terms of depth (supposedly) so trading picks would not worry me as much.

anyone who saw him interviewed on footy classified would realize that if it were up to fevola, he would definitely be at cartlton next season.

recent interviews of ratten explicity say he wants fevola at carlton next season.

therefore...he will be going nowhere

He sure did wonders with Zantuck, Murphy and Cupido.

Some times there are those that just can't be helped !!!

Why would he come to us. He mentioned that he would want to stay at Carlton next year + with our young developing forward line getting better, I would rather pick up a young forward in the draft next year.

Any player over 26 on our list has to have a positive affect on the rest of the list, and a bloke who after he gets dragged takes off his boots and refuses to go back on does not fit into that category. A great FF he could be, a leader he definitely isn't.

Any player over 26 on our list has to have a positive affect on the rest of the list, and a bloke who after he gets dragged takes off his boots and refuses to go back on does not fit into that category. A great FF he could be, a leader he definitely isn't.

Yep.

I wouldn't take Fevola if he paid us to come to the club. If we're genuinely concerned about a lack of on-field leadership at the club, then we can't go and pick up someone who has never played a game in his career without spitting the dummy at his teammates. I can't think of a player I'd rather play alongside less than Fev. It's one thing to be highly talented, but the fact that he's had almost a decade in the league to grow up and play team footy means that he's highly unlikely to change.

Fev is the biggest wan*** in the afl. I utterly hate him so much. He makes himself look stupid on the footy show, he says "the team cant win without me...and im really important to the team structure" on footy classified and hes out of control on the field. Fev has the size of 1 hundred and thousand as a brain and no way would i want him at melb. We are still developing...lets get newton at FF after neitz departs and start recruiting by trading likes of Bruce and TJ

Why would he come to us. He mentioned that he would want to stay at Carlton next year + with our young developing forward line getting better, I would rather pick up a young forward in the draft next year.

TO RIGHT WOULDNT WANT IM IF HE CAME CRAWLING

Fev is the biggest wan*** in the afl. I utterly hate him so much. He makes himself look stupid on the footy show, he says "the team cant win without me...and im really important to the team structure" on footy classified and hes out of control on the field. Fev has the size of 1 hundred and thousand as a brain and no way would i want him at melb. We are still developing...lets get newton at FF after neitz departs and start recruiting by trading likes of Bruce and TJ

Agree 100% occo