St Kilda has just re-signed Nick Reiwoldt and Nick Del Santo for 3 years each. That's two Nicks off our shopping list! Bummer but no real shock is it?

St Kilda has just re-signed Nick Reiwoldt and Nick Del Santo for 3 years each. That's two Nicks off our shopping list! Bummer but no real shock is it?

Matt Maguire remains unsigned.

OK - He'll do........

Matt Maguire remains unsigned.

I think the last thing we need is another undersized key position player. Who will no doubt be over-priced...

lets bring back nick smith

I think the last thing we need is another undersized key position player.

Oh yeah, tiny little fella that he is .........

Oh yeah, tiny little fella that he is .........

Yeah i wouldnt say he was small. He is bigger than any of our defenders. He would be an awesome pick up for our weak defence but we would never get him....

I was shocked to see on the back of my son's footy card the other day that Matt Maguire is actually 190cm - hardly small!

I was shocked to see on the back of my son's footy card the other day that Matt Maguire is actually 190cm - hardly small!

Yeah hardly small but still shorter than Carroll, Ferguson, Frawley, Garland, Holland, Miller and Warnock.

I was shocked to see on the back of my son's footy card the other day that Matt Maguire is actually 190cm - hardly small!

That's funny, he is listed on the Saints site as being 192cm !!!

And he may not be quite as tall as some of our defenders (although he seems very strong, still plays on the big opposition forwards, and does do it pretty well) but he is, and this is just my opinion, a more solid and generally better player than most, if not all of our "bigger" defencive options.

That's funny, he is listed on the Saints site as being 192cm !!!

And he may not be quite as tall as some of our defenders (although he seems very strong, still plays on the big opposition forwards, and does do it pretty well) but he is, and this is just my opinion, a more solid and generally better player than most, if not all of our "bigger" defencive options.

Still undersized IMO...

Did u see him this week against Adelaide?

Was tossed around like a rag doll early against Bock. Giving away both height and weight, he ended up conceding 3 or 4 free just because of his lack of size. Too similar in stature to Carroll for my liking. A very good 3rd defensive option, but not #1 backman IMHO

I would have thought that that could have something to do with the fact he was coming back from a massive injury and is still rusty.

And unfortunately for us he is a far better footballer and stronger defender than Carroll will ever be IMO.