Welcome Choke. Worse things have happened than agree with olisik. I just can't quite think of any ATM........

I can... Could have been Tonatopia...

But thanks

People need to stop bagging everything to do with Cale. While he hasn't developed like we hoped, his first season was very good, probably the best of anyone on our list, and one of the best in my lifetime following the Dees. He didn't just get cheap kicks, he had a genuine impact and was being talked about as the best pick of that draft. I remember one game against the eventual premiers Geelong where he picked up 30 odd touches, but not only that, he played up forward for a quarter and kicked 3 on Scarlett, even out-marking him in the goal square at one stage.

The Cale bashing is over the top, and it's frustrating how violently Melbourne supporters turn on their own. While it's obvious he hasn't come on like we hoped, both in body and form, he had a fantastic start to his career, and to say otherwise shows you are either just attacking him mindlessly or you know [censored] all about football.

Why? Even if what you say is right (and its not my recollection) it would have been in 2008 - 5 seasons ago! I'd say you know less than the poster you are criticising.

is Tippett back on the table if he doesn'ttt go to Swannies and would he be good for us? I think so! This is why Crow's are so upset.

He goes back into the draft I believe where GC are likely to pick him up....