I think Davey will start as the sub, I don't believe he can get a through a full game, Tapscott to start and likely to sub him out into the third quarter. My line up

Bartram Sellar Frawley

Morton Rivers Garland

Bate Grimes Trengove

Howe Watts McDonald

Tapscott Clark Dunn

Jamar Jones Magner

Martin McKenzie Bail

Davey

Wow, considering you see the game differently to the rest of us, I might have to snap up some of that $4 being offered for a Melbourne win. Will "probably" win wouldn't fill me with confidence if I were a Toiges supporter, especially coming from your keyboard BH!

Sellars MUST play on Vickery when he goes forward. I'm one of very few that actually sees a lot of potential in Vickery, and from memory, both games last year against us he was their main forward (due to the standard Frawley job on Reiwoldt). Jury's out for me with Sellar, but they've come back after brief deliberation regarding Rivers and it aint flash.

I have to say that Petterd needs to lift his intensity and actually go and get the ball. While it is hard to criticse our forwards at the moment, due to the standard of our midfield, when you play on the half forward flank like Petterd does (and is best suited), you need to be just as effective in the midfield, and be able to generate your own possession. He and Howe are, in my view, fighting for the same spot, especially when Sylvia comes back, and I honestly believe Howe does more than Ricky Bobby.

Sellars MUST play on Vickery when he goes forward. I'm one of very few that actually sees a lot of potential in Vickery, and from memory, both games last year against us he was their main forward (due to the standard Frawley job on Reiwoldt). Jury's out for me with Sellar, but they've come back after brief deliberation regarding Rivers and it aint flash.

I agree but I wanted Rivers Deep (Mountain high sorry) for Rivers to come across 3rd man cover for Chip.

So I think we need Riv in the side, so for the whole team balance, I had Sellar on the interchange, but many things could happen, Morton may start as sub: or Bate again. so Sellar could be in.

I have to say that Petterd needs to lift his intensity and actually go and get the ball.

Agree, I cam imagine Ricky being a Spontaneous type player, would take a bit of time to feel the freedom he needs, in such a structured game style, to actually let loose & go for his footy free minded.

.

How tough are our Selectors when anyone dropped goes straight on to the Emg list for the game. Last week Davey this week Green.

Davey wasn't dropped last week, of this I'm sure.

Think what of that re Green, as you will.

I think Davey will start as the sub, I don't believe he can get a through a full game, Tapscott to start and likely to sub him out into the third quarter. My line up

Bartram Sellar Frawley

Morton Rivers Garland

Bate Grimes Trengove

Howe Watts McDonald

Tapscott Clark Dunn

Jamar Jones Magner

Martin McKenzie Bail

Davey

If that were the Case, I would start with the hard bodied Tapscott, then switch after half time.