Melbourne Football Club Under 21 Best 22

[Guest Schtacker]

Look I don't think Jones is a bad footballer and in hindsight I really was having a bit of a troll ranking him 16th on my talent list.

However.....

How many times have you seen Jones hit a forward lace out?

Don't give me crap how about that's not his specific role. All "A" grade inside midfielders in the modern game e.g. your Sam Mitchell's and Joel Corey's have far superior kicking skills to Jones. If were going to challenge for a premiship he needs to get his kicking up to scratch or either pick up about 20 hard ball gets a game just to justify his position.

I for one more than anyone hopes Jonesy can improve on these deficiencies in his game.

I remember against North this year we were getting smashed of course, could not buy a goal. There was a bounce on our forward 50 line and Jonesy just sharked it from the pack and stuck it on the boot and it sailed through, he knew that was the only way we were getting a goal so he just did it - it was a remarkable goal that went fairly unnoticed in the wash up of yet another horrible thumping. I was sold on him at that moment. The way he digs the ball out is first rate and he is about our only bloke that can do it. He's an absolute gem and will only keep getting better. Also, the side around him will strengthen and then he will really sparkle. You watch, he will fix his disposal and learn the tricks of being an inside mid and he will be one of our premier players for a long time. Star.

[rpfc 28,262]

Nathan is a talent but he needs to learn how to handball in tight, and kick to advantage.

[damon the demon 57]

No he isn't, he had a 70% efficiency rate this year while doing it all on his own in the packs in the middle. While it isn't a great efficiency rate it obviously can be worked on.

It's funny how people on this site go with the groupthink, one week people were praising him then as a couple of people start bagging him everyone jumps on.

A good example of this was his game against West Coast where he got 30 posessions at 90% efficiency, an outstanding match overall. Then people on this site were bagging him after the match for his bad disposal Sometimes i wonder if people actually watch the game and form their own opinions.

after round 2 this year i recall a plethora of posts saying that garland should never play again (when he was hardly in our worst players). footy will always have a mob mentality aspect and while this site is often very insightful, it too is not immune from the odd bandwagon bash. jones will be back in favour soon enough.