dennis jones

Concerned we're coming back from Perth and 31 degrees! Tom McDonald said he lost 3 kilos! Needed everything to go our way to win this one- hope I'm wrong.

Redman - you are absolutely correct in your summary! My point is come out NOW and state that Viney is not definitely ours and call the bluff of Sheedy. Sadly, i believe we're to far down the line to show this courage and I am extremely fearful that Jack does not warrant pick 3. Even if he does, our actions have all but precluded us for getting him at a 'bargain' in the second round. To be honest this is far harder to swallow than the 100+ point loss to the Eagles etc.

Sorry about that! Surely we have made a huge error with regard to the very public acceptance of him into our club. Would it not be too late to tear up the 'heads of agreement' ,with Todd and Jack's knowledge, and tell the football world we will not be using our first pick on him? In effect, we will be calling the bluff of GWS and others into taking him first ,running the risk they will miss on Whitfield etc.- a risk they will be unwilling to take. As it stands, we will be taking Viney pick 3 or 4 in the hope he is that good! If others pass we will get him in the second round. If they nominate him we can still take him, although unethical. We have the possibility of securing 3 first rounders + Viney- at least that is my understanding- sadly I think the horse has well and truly bolted!