demon3165

Think the failure is masked by the team's success. He should be elite, up there with the best mids going round. Goodie is extremely stubborn. He stuck fat with Oscar McD for ages & persisted with Fritter & Harmes played out of position long after most supporters had worked it out. I agree I still believe he should be in the guts full stop, Trac, Clarry and Gus seem to have a connection when he gets the chance to get in there.

He has a lot to learn but you can only really do that with good players around you thats what good teams do bring one in and help them, having said that he has some limitations at the moment as I would not put him on a Dangerfield etc but give him time.

And some people said the same thing about Petty when he came in!!

Clarry has the cleanest hand picking up a football and hand ball but does not hurt enough teams by foot when he learns to lower the eyes and take that half second to pass thats when he will really go up another notch he also has to learn how to deal with a hard tag but thats a coaching and mental thing.

Just wait till he has another two pre seasons he will be an absolute gun.

Lol but I want to know who listened to it cause no one can hear us, are you hearing voices in your head?

Noticed the Jason Dunstall method of goal kicking this weekend just run in and kick straight over the man on the mark!!

Well just as well I don't believe in god then so he wont hurt me......

He was a complete flop in Perth and whats that got to do with it now.

Gus into the guts for a start that leaves Rugby player out May and TMac in could try another for the wing position Rivers, Spargo?

Lmfao Viney would be spent by quarter time with amount of running Selwood does.

If Hawkins got rubbed out for that then the AFL is a joke nothing in it pure football accident.

Unfortunately that will be the case.

And viney does that every game.

How long has this kid been in the system? compared to Viney will back this kid in before Viney more upside.

Will take Hibbo;s spot.

Yep he has been damm shocking should be hung from the highest, tree think you went a bit early there.

Why, Viney is just a rugby player cannot kick, not a big mark and no football awareness, so no not a lot of upside for me.

Would have him on the list before Viney.

First on Jones a great warrior for the club without doubt but time has gone bye to slow now and if played as a sub its just a waste, yes he played well in the VFL but so he should. Hibberd yes I agree he did play well against those players but Dusty spends a little more time forward than Danger does, but it looks like he won't be there and Hibberd he has not been playing well but the up side Petty and Bowey have slotted in the backline without a hiccup the youth sure helps Lever and May out. The other player that must come out is AVB just like Jones to slow and a shocking decision maker the days of the bull in the China shop way of playing has gone for now that is why AVB, Jones and Viney will always struggle in today's game.

In Jones and hibberd, might as well bring in Wells and Healy.

Lets not get carried away with the win against GGS they were shocking, our last quarter was woeful only one goal scored great sides bury teams like them I still remember 186 the forward line still has a lot of work to do to be a potent force but at least they are working on it.

Well we all have have own views on it, just yours is wrong......lol

Oliver and Trac need to learn one thing you don't have to throw the ball an the boot as their first option great players take that extra half second or two and deliver it lace out when they both do that that will elevate them to another level hope choco is working on that.

Harmes has been in the system many years it is not about being polished its about knowing your limitations and playing to them and understanding your role his first instinct is what Viney does try to fend of and bight off more than you chew and that is the coaches fault but it needs to get it out of his game.