dees189227

These umpires are shocking. Petracca gets held onto in our 50, nothing. Goldsetin just runs thorugh the protected space, nothing. In saying that we haven't helpe dourselves. any chance of manning up these nth players. They are just allowed to get free and how about we stick a tackle. God twice we let goldstein get out of one. Also how about kicking goals. Petracca is at the level where he should be nailing those.

I'm not confident what so ever, however we win today we go up to 9th. That's important. I also hope Eddie, Derm and dwayne are not calling the match.

Nothing against brisbance because I like them, but I hope the dogs win tonight just to go above collingwood and jump ahead of essenscum.

Lets hope port can roll the tigs in the second half

Port should be further ahead. Dixon has missed some sitters.

I just thought it be obvious Jones would captain.

Dam 2 big outs. Our mids might want to study up goldstein. He will have a field day. Gee Viney is a huge loss. also loses Gawn's impact in the backline. So how did Viney get concussion?

They just discussed it on mmm. Said melbourne should definitely appeal and if that was the bont or martin no way would they have got 4 weeks. Sid he should have got 1 or 2 at most

Well the precedence has been set. Any player who does the same thing has to get the same result. I would have thought maybe 2 weeks. His good record should have been taken into account. I doubt he will play this week but if Will Hamill does play the 4 weeks would look stupid.

I saw it when they sang the song last week and I thought how weird. What possesses another person to do that. But it has happened more than once. I mean if I'm Short or Vlastuin I'd look back and think why would I do that. Would I really want someone doing that to me. Just sing the song and be done with it. But I kind of like how Dimma got taken to task on it. I bet after the presser there was a bit of scrambling going on to see what happened.

Don't agree with the decision either but happy to see essendon lose especially when they were about to kick into there 50 when the siren sounded. They were 5 goals up and got ran over. But yeah I mean with the talent gws have they should be well up the ladder. I know they had no Toby tonight but there midfield is still pretty good. anyway essendon lost. Good.

What a snoozefest

Come on giants big win tonight. Smash them

Dam sydney had there chances in that final term. Papley missed shots he'd usually kick and when they were 2 points down 3 swans players just handballed to each other instead of 1 choosing to take shot when they were all open. Dam that would have been great to see them knocked off, but in fairness the goal by Daicos was awesome. The saints suns game is really enjoyable so far. Not fussed who wins.

Talking about the commentary, give me Mark Howard or Huddo anyday. Ed and Derm should not be on together because they don't focus on the game and rather act as if they are sitting round a table talking about the past. Dwayne is just annoying. Kingy is ok but I wonder why he never went into coaching. The way he analyses the game makes him sound like a coach. also well done on Goody calling out the off the ball treatment Maxy gets off the ball. I know after his presser the fox footy team didn't agree with goody doing that but he is obviously had enough of the treatment.

It makes a difference the next day after your team has won. The thing I liked after our win was on the final siren seeing the smile back on Goody's face. Look we only beat the bottom team but it was a good last quarter. Jackson was great last night and viney from start to finish was just awesome. I also thought May was really good as well.

That was a disgrace. Melksham had a shot and we just gave it back. Umps are trying to stamp that rubbish out. No need for vandenberg to do it. Ugh the crows are going in hard because they know we are a mentality soft team. Viney is just going in hard as a bull. Come on dees, don't get sucked in. Oh and a message to the commentators. Commentate the game. Gee with ed, Dwyane, Derm & kingy all they seem to have done is talk about old stories.

I expect the cats to win this. All I want to see this week is the giants smash the bummers.

I have no idea what to expect. If we lose it wouldn't surprise me. I've been a melbourne fan long enough to know tonight is a danger game. But I expect us to win and if we do it probably still won't satisfy the media or fans.

Dixon getting the job done one end, bruce struggling down the other. Seriously he has been a shocking recruit. Fumbles, dropping marks that he should take and this season his kicking has been ordinary. In saying that the time we play them he will have the perfect game.

Both essendon and collingwood losing is always a great weekend, even better if we can win. Gee bucks has had a good week. Wonder how ed went watching that game.

Gee just imagine if the saints didn't give up there big leads and lose to nth and freo

I'm already thinking of the media outcry. Sadly I'm already preparing myself

Ha Gil would just be shaking his head. Wonder how that phone call went between Bucks and Ed. Seriously you cannot make this stuff up. The senior coach should have known better. Back here in melbourne even I know you can't go out and mix with others. Oh well Brooke Cotchin will be happy the focus has been taken off her.